Advertisement

French politician proposes 'lottery' for compulsory military service for immigrants

Emma Pearson
Emma Pearson - emma.pearson@thelocal.com
French politician proposes 'lottery' for compulsory military service for immigrants
Louis Sarkozy, son of France's former president Nicolas Sarkozy, and candidate in next year's local elections. Photo by JULIEN DE ROSA / AFP
Add The Local as a preferred source

Louis Sarkozy - son of the ex president and a candidate in next year's elections - has unveiled a plan to create a lottery to force new arrivals in France to do military service.

Sarkozy junior, 28, has spent most of his life in the US but has recently returned to France with the intention of entering politics - he intends to stand in next year's elections to become mayor of the small lemon-producing town of Menton in south-east France.

Speaking to RMC radio, he revealed that he believes that military service should be extended in France but that it should be voluntary - for most people. 

However he wants military service to be compulsory for criminals, imposed as part of a judicial sentence, and for some immigrants.

"Why not introduce a lottery - say 10 percent - whereby all new legal immigrants would be obliged to serve in the army?" said Sarkozy.

"Firstly, this would act as a clear deterrent: many would hesitate to join us for fear of having to serve in uniform. Secondly, it would guarantee us a solid vector for assimilation."

He did not clarify what he meant by 'new' immigrants, whether his plan would distinguish between EU and non-EU citizens or whether there would be any consideration given to age, disability or medical conditions.

"You have to read Lyautey, in 1891, Le rôle social de l'officier (the social role of an officer)," he added. "He explained that the army is the great school of the nation, the place where workers and students, believers and atheists, rural and urban dwellers come together.

"When you put everyone in uniform, there are no clans, no Muslims or Christians, no categories. There's still one nation."

Even if Sarkozy is successful in his bid to become mayor of Menton, he would not have the power to force his constituents to join the army.

However his comments come in the context of a wider discussion about the return of voluntary military service.

At present only French citizens can join the French armed forces, with the exception of the Légion étrangere (French Foreign Legion) which accepts non-French citizens.

The Legion takes part in regular French military commitments both overseas and at home, including providing soldiers for Operation Sentinelle, the security operation that guards potential sites of terror attacks such as stations, airports and tourist sites.

Advertisement

Foreigners who have served for five years in the Legion, or two years and have been injured in the line of duty, are eligible to apply for French citizenship.

READ ALSO: Everything you need to know about the French Foreign Legion

More

Comments (5)

Join the conversation in our comments section below. Share your own views and experience and if you have a question or suggestion for our journalists then email us at news@thelocal.fr.
Please keep comments civil, constructive and on topic – and make sure to read our terms of use before getting involved.

Please log in to leave a comment.

All comments 5
Sort by
M.J. Wilkie
I agree with all the comments. "We don't like immigrants, but they are useful for military service." Do they really think that giving a convicted criminal a gun is a good idea?! These are the people who lead the nation?!?!
Donald Hanson
More appropriate to find those who have committed serious crimes to be inadmissible to the honor of military service. Concerning foreigners, if they volunteer, it could be considered. But their home country may prohibit serving in a foreign army. Is France going to give them citizenship first? Politicians should think things through before opening their mouths. Bad ideas can be hard to live down for the rest of their careers.
Radu Kristiansand, NO
This guy wants to end immigration to France, condemning it to poverty.
M Carmona
That's a really awful idea. Using compulsory military service as a punishment or crime deterrent diminishes the value of men and women in uniform serving their country. What France and all the other NATO countries need at the moment are precisely the opposite; committed, dedicated, honourable, brave and smart men and women, not cannon fodder.
Carmela S
Ah, yes, it is SUCH a good idea to give a criminal a gun and put him/her in a position of power, both over people and over resources and teach them about supply chain pipelines that can be used for smuggling or anything, you know, criminal. And yes, of COURSE a military uniform "unifies" and eliminates any racial bias- look at the "Affaire Dreyfus". This young Sarkozy obviously has not thought things through, or maybe lacks life experience (j'accuse).

See Also