Greens see red over giant Paris billboards
A host of Paris landmarks - from the Opera Garnier to the Obelisk of Luxor on the Place de la Concorde and part of the Louvre Museum - have been covered by giant billboards in recent years, and now questions are being asked about the capital's 'eyesores'.
Local representatives of the Greens are particularly angry about a giant hoarding on a new Louis Vuitton store soon to open on the famed Champs-Elysées.
The building, owned by luxury giant LVMH, is covered in scaffolding and draped in a protective covering that resembles a Louis Vuitton trunk, one of the brand's flagship products.
Ecologist councillors have written to Paris mayor Anne Hidalgo, questioning the legality of the hoarding.
Billboards are allowed on listed historic buildings to finance facade work, but the law says adverts must not make up more than half of the protective covering, the Greens insist.
"In this case, we're talking about more than 50 percent, since they are covering the roof as well," Green politician Emile Meunier, co-sponsor of the question, told AFP.
In a written statement to AFP, Paris authorities responded that in this case, "the tarpaulin is not considered to be advertising because the building belongs to LVMH."
The authorities "will ask the owner to pay a tax of €1.7 million for the duration of its installation, which is scheduled to run until 2027," the statement said.
It added that Architectes des Batiments de France, the official body overseeing planning for historic buildings, has given "approval".
Contacted by AFP, neither LVMH nor the Ministry of Culture - which is responsible for heritage issues - were willing to comment.
LVMH's founder and chief executive Bernard Arnault is currently the world's second-richest person after Elon Musk, according to Forbes.
But the Louis Vuitton store is one of many examples.
For a number of years, a number of listed Parisian buildings have been hidden behind huge advertising tarpaulins while work was carried out: the Museum of Decorative Arts in a wing of the Louvre; the famous obelisk on the Place de la Concorde; the Opera Garnier, the Madeleine church with its majestic Greek columns; and some facades of the Place des Vosges.
"At some point, people have to be able to enjoy the beauty of their city without being assaulted by injunctions to consume more and more," said Meunier, who said he opposed "the principle of advertising altogether".
"As an ecologist, I'm against advertising, particularly in the public space; I see it as an aggression and a boost to over-consumption", he said.
Nevertheless, Jeanne d'Hauteserre, the right-wing mayor of the eighth arrondissement which includes the Champs-Elysées, said that as soon as she took office in 2014, she gave the green light to billboard advertising on churches undergoing renovation in order to cut costs and speed up the refurbishment.
A former advertising executive, the district mayor hit back at critics, saying that buildings allowed to fall into disrepair would become a danger.
"The day they get something falling on their heads, they'll be happy!" she said.
As for the LVMH project, "either we get an ugly tarpaulin, or we get a pretty, improved tarpaulin", she said.
"From the moment restoration work is needed, there has to be one."
Passers-by on the Champs-Elysées expressed mixed feelings about the Louis Vuitton billboards.
"I think it's nicer than rotting scaffolding", Beatrice Boue, a resident of Antony, in the southern suburbs, told AFP.
"I don't particularly like (it)," said Lucyna Milosz, a Polish tourist.
"I understand they have to cover it, but I don't like when there are pictures. As long as there is no commercial it's fine. They should have it covered and hurry up!" she laughed.
Comments
See Also
Local representatives of the Greens are particularly angry about a giant hoarding on a new Louis Vuitton store soon to open on the famed Champs-Elysées.
The building, owned by luxury giant LVMH, is covered in scaffolding and draped in a protective covering that resembles a Louis Vuitton trunk, one of the brand's flagship products.
Ecologist councillors have written to Paris mayor Anne Hidalgo, questioning the legality of the hoarding.
Billboards are allowed on listed historic buildings to finance facade work, but the law says adverts must not make up more than half of the protective covering, the Greens insist.
"In this case, we're talking about more than 50 percent, since they are covering the roof as well," Green politician Emile Meunier, co-sponsor of the question, told AFP.
In a written statement to AFP, Paris authorities responded that in this case, "the tarpaulin is not considered to be advertising because the building belongs to LVMH."
The authorities "will ask the owner to pay a tax of €1.7 million for the duration of its installation, which is scheduled to run until 2027," the statement said.
It added that Architectes des Batiments de France, the official body overseeing planning for historic buildings, has given "approval".
Contacted by AFP, neither LVMH nor the Ministry of Culture - which is responsible for heritage issues - were willing to comment.
LVMH's founder and chief executive Bernard Arnault is currently the world's second-richest person after Elon Musk, according to Forbes.
But the Louis Vuitton store is one of many examples.
For a number of years, a number of listed Parisian buildings have been hidden behind huge advertising tarpaulins while work was carried out: the Museum of Decorative Arts in a wing of the Louvre; the famous obelisk on the Place de la Concorde; the Opera Garnier, the Madeleine church with its majestic Greek columns; and some facades of the Place des Vosges.
"At some point, people have to be able to enjoy the beauty of their city without being assaulted by injunctions to consume more and more," said Meunier, who said he opposed "the principle of advertising altogether".
"As an ecologist, I'm against advertising, particularly in the public space; I see it as an aggression and a boost to over-consumption", he said.
Nevertheless, Jeanne d'Hauteserre, the right-wing mayor of the eighth arrondissement which includes the Champs-Elysées, said that as soon as she took office in 2014, she gave the green light to billboard advertising on churches undergoing renovation in order to cut costs and speed up the refurbishment.
A former advertising executive, the district mayor hit back at critics, saying that buildings allowed to fall into disrepair would become a danger.
"The day they get something falling on their heads, they'll be happy!" she said.
As for the LVMH project, "either we get an ugly tarpaulin, or we get a pretty, improved tarpaulin", she said.
"From the moment restoration work is needed, there has to be one."
Passers-by on the Champs-Elysées expressed mixed feelings about the Louis Vuitton billboards.
"I think it's nicer than rotting scaffolding", Beatrice Boue, a resident of Antony, in the southern suburbs, told AFP.
"I don't particularly like (it)," said Lucyna Milosz, a Polish tourist.
"I understand they have to cover it, but I don't like when there are pictures. As long as there is no commercial it's fine. They should have it covered and hurry up!" she laughed.
Join the conversation in our comments section below. Share your own views and experience and if you have a question or suggestion for our journalists then email us at [email protected].
Please keep comments civil, constructive and on topic – and make sure to read our terms of use before getting involved.
Please log in here to leave a comment.