French court fines government record sum over air pollution
France's top administrative court on Wednesday fined the government a record sum for failing to reduce air pollution to acceptable levels.
The Council of State slapped its highest fine ever, €10 million, on President Emmanuel Macron's government, warning it would do so again within months if the authorities failed to act quickly to combat smog.
The Court, which has become increasingly watchful over the government's environmental record, said measures decided by the government were insufficient to improve air quality, because some might not actually be implemented, and their likely effects had not been properly evaluated.
Last year, the Council ruled that the government had failed to implement a court order dating from 2017 to curb air pollution levels, and gave it six months to take corrective action or face a €10 million fine every six months until air quality improves.
With the six-month deadline having elapsed, the Council is now implementing its threat.
Air pollution is believed to cause 40,000 premature deaths in France per year.
READ ALSO Why we need to get used to summer storms and floods in France
The Court said that pollution by nitrogen dioxide - produced by fossil fuel combustion, notably by cars - was still excessive in five urban areas: Paris, Lyon, Marseille-Aix, Toulouse and Grenoble.
It also singled out Paris for persistently high levels of PM10 micro particle pollution.
The Court said it will examine air pollution levels again at the start of 2022 and could impose another fine which could come in "above or below" the latest one, depending on the outcome.
The Council said the fine issued Wednesday would be mostly shared among various anti-air pollution agencies.
NGO Friends of the Earth, which launched the pollution lawsuit against the government, will get 100,000 euros, the judges ruled.
Comments
See Also
The Council of State slapped its highest fine ever, €10 million, on President Emmanuel Macron's government, warning it would do so again within months if the authorities failed to act quickly to combat smog.
The Court, which has become increasingly watchful over the government's environmental record, said measures decided by the government were insufficient to improve air quality, because some might not actually be implemented, and their likely effects had not been properly evaluated.
Last year, the Council ruled that the government had failed to implement a court order dating from 2017 to curb air pollution levels, and gave it six months to take corrective action or face a €10 million fine every six months until air quality improves.
With the six-month deadline having elapsed, the Council is now implementing its threat.
Air pollution is believed to cause 40,000 premature deaths in France per year.
READ ALSO Why we need to get used to summer storms and floods in France
The Court said that pollution by nitrogen dioxide - produced by fossil fuel combustion, notably by cars - was still excessive in five urban areas: Paris, Lyon, Marseille-Aix, Toulouse and Grenoble.
It also singled out Paris for persistently high levels of PM10 micro particle pollution.
The Court said it will examine air pollution levels again at the start of 2022 and could impose another fine which could come in "above or below" the latest one, depending on the outcome.
The Council said the fine issued Wednesday would be mostly shared among various anti-air pollution agencies.
NGO Friends of the Earth, which launched the pollution lawsuit against the government, will get 100,000 euros, the judges ruled.
Join the conversation in our comments section below. Share your own views and experience and if you have a question or suggestion for our journalists then email us at [email protected].
Please keep comments civil, constructive and on topic – and make sure to read our terms of use before getting involved.
Please log in here to leave a comment.