EXPLAINED: What does laïcité (secularism) really mean in France?
Often at the centre of heated debates, France's state secularism is not always clearly understood by either its proponents or critics. Here's a look at what "laïcité" really means.
Laîcité, usually translated as secularism, is in brief the principle that everyone in France has the freedom to worship as they choose - but the state itself remains strictly neutral and does not take part in any religious practices.
However that seemingly straightforward concept is the cause of an increasing number of battles and misunderstandings.
Here's a closer look at what it means.
What is the definition of secularism?
“There is no one single definition of the concept of secularism," stated a report by France’s Conseil d’Etat, the legal advisor to the government, titled Un siècle de laïcité (One Century of secularism).
“Untranslatable in most languages, the concept of secularism refers, in the broad sense, to a loss of hold by religion on society," they wrote.
The report was published in 2004, ahead of the 100-year-anniversary of the 1905 law that became the bedrock of French secularism by formally separating religious and State matters in France.
While that law - Law on Separation of the Churches and State - did not actually employ the term laïcité, it is the number one legal reference for the principle of secularism today in France.
Where does it come from?
Secularism's roots go back to French Revolution of 1789. Enlightenment thinkers felt reason and universal values had to be protected.
The 19th century saw a battle between the "two Frances", with secular republicans struggling to contain the power of the dominant Catholic Church.
After 1862, when education became free and secular, that battle became a culture war. Secular schoolteachers - nicknamed the "Black Hussars of the Republic" after their black coats - took on the Catholic clergy for the hearts and minds of every village in France.
Laïcité was enshrined in the French Constitution in 1946. Article 1 states "La France est une République laïque" (France is a secular republic).
Is it only French?
France’s secularism has influenced many countries including Mexico, which also used it to counter the power of the Catholic Church.
But it was most whole-heartedly taken up in Muslim-majority Turkey by it modern founder Ataturk. Turkey's current president, Recep Tayyip Erdogan, has spent much of his 17 years in power trying to roll that back.
What exactly does it mean?
It's a complicated matter, which is not made easier by the fact that there is no clear, simple definition of the term.
But secularism is a principle that is supposed to evolve with the times, legal scholars have stressed.
The French government has a website page dedicated to the question Qu'est-ce que la laïcité ? (What is secularism?).
Their long explanation can be summed up in four core principles, collected from a 2013 legal decision by the French Constitutional Council, the body in charge of reviewing constitutionality of French laws. These are:
- state neutrality;
- respect for all beliefs and equality of all citizens before the law without distinction of religion;
- freedom to worship;
- the absence of official worship.
What does that mean in practice?
Secularism in France is a principle meant to guarantee freedom for each individual to believe whatever they want and exercise this right as they please without interference from the state.
At the same time, religion must be exercised in the private, not public, sphere.
The state must be neutral, which means that public officials cannot wear religious signs. Crosses, hijabs, kippahs and other religious clothing or symbols are therefore banned from public institutions such as schools and for public officials on duty (teachers, police officers, firefighters).
There are also no displays of religion in public institutions, so schools do not have prayer meetings, religious assemblies or religious events such as Nativity Plays at Christmas.
Are there exceptions?
In France, there are nearly always exceptions to a rule. Despite its strict secularism, French public holidays still mark Christian holidays including Christmas, Easter and more obscure ones like Assumption and Ascension Day.
At the same time, far-right party Rassemblement National has not yet succeeded in its mission to decorate French town and city halls with Christian cribs at Christmas. That said, official buildings such as mairies do put up decorations at Christmas, usually some nice twinkly lights that are festive without being overtly Christian.
Secular laws do not, however, apply in quite the same way in the eastern borderlands of Alsace-Lorraine, where Christian and Jewish clerics are paid by the state, for historical reasons linked to wars with Germany.
READ MORE: EXPLAINED: Does France really have a hijab ban?
Is it changing in modern time?
French secularism has been on the defensive since the late 1980s with the emergence of identity politics, Christian and Jewish revivalism and most of all, radical Islam, given the movement of Muslims from its former colonies since the 1950s.
In 2004 France banned "the wearing of conspicuous religious symbols or garb" in state schools. It became known as "the French headscarf ban" abroad, though it applies to symbols of all religions.
In 2010 France banned the niqab, the full-face veil, in public places - although this law was eventually framed as a security concern and actually covers all full-face coverings. Several local authorities had attempted to ban the burkini, the full-cover swimsuit, on their beaches, but this was overturned by the courts.
What does it NOT mean?
Secularism is often misunderstood in France today, even by government officials. In September, a French MP of ruling party La République en Marche caused a stir when she refused to participate in a parliamentary session together with a Muslim woman who was wearing the headscarf.
1- Meanwhile in #France, the so-called color-blind nation: a French MP stormed out of an audition at the National Assembly because she found the presence of a Muslim woman wearing a Hijab unbearable and contrary to the values of the Republic. pic.twitter.com/EZcpOvQUMU
— Rim-Sarah Alouane (@RimSarah) September 17, 2020
While MPs and staff in public buildings in France are forbidden from wearing religious clothing, that rule does not apply to visitors, like the woman in question.
As a citizen and not a public official, she was exercising her right to religious freedom in accordance with French law cited above.
“The problem we are seeing today is that we want to impose neutrality on individuals, which is the opposite of laïcité," said Rim-Sarah Alouane, a French legal scholar and law Phd candidate who specialises in religious freedom, human rights and civil liberties in France, Europe and North America.Alouane told The Local she prefers not to translate laïcité to secularism, for accuracy purposes.
France's interior minister also caused uproar when he said supermarket chains should abolish their separate food aisles for ethnic foods. The comment, which was hailed by some rightwing commentators as a bold defence of secularism, caused critics to call out the interior minister as misusing the core principle to further his own political agenda.
As private businesses supermarkets - and all other stores - are not bound to observe laïcité in the same way as government agencies and public officials.
ANALYSIS: Why does France's interior minister think supermarket ethnic food isles are a threat to the nation?
Similarly, sports retailer Decathlon was attacked on the grounds of laïcité for offering a 'running hijab', although as a private business catering to private individuals it was perfectly entitled to offer the headgear.
“Interfering with religious matters in this way is in itself a violation of laïcité," Alouane said then.
"Laïcité is freedom."
Comments
See Also
Laîcité, usually translated as secularism, is in brief the principle that everyone in France has the freedom to worship as they choose - but the state itself remains strictly neutral and does not take part in any religious practices.
However that seemingly straightforward concept is the cause of an increasing number of battles and misunderstandings.
Here's a closer look at what it means.
What is the definition of secularism?
“There is no one single definition of the concept of secularism," stated a report by France’s Conseil d’Etat, the legal advisor to the government, titled Un siècle de laïcité (One Century of secularism).
“Untranslatable in most languages, the concept of secularism refers, in the broad sense, to a loss of hold by religion on society," they wrote.
The report was published in 2004, ahead of the 100-year-anniversary of the 1905 law that became the bedrock of French secularism by formally separating religious and State matters in France.
While that law - Law on Separation of the Churches and State - did not actually employ the term laïcité, it is the number one legal reference for the principle of secularism today in France.
Where does it come from?
Secularism's roots go back to French Revolution of 1789. Enlightenment thinkers felt reason and universal values had to be protected.
The 19th century saw a battle between the "two Frances", with secular republicans struggling to contain the power of the dominant Catholic Church.
After 1862, when education became free and secular, that battle became a culture war. Secular schoolteachers - nicknamed the "Black Hussars of the Republic" after their black coats - took on the Catholic clergy for the hearts and minds of every village in France.
Laïcité was enshrined in the French Constitution in 1946. Article 1 states "La France est une République laïque" (France is a secular republic).
Is it only French?
France’s secularism has influenced many countries including Mexico, which also used it to counter the power of the Catholic Church.
But it was most whole-heartedly taken up in Muslim-majority Turkey by it modern founder Ataturk. Turkey's current president, Recep Tayyip Erdogan, has spent much of his 17 years in power trying to roll that back.
What exactly does it mean?
It's a complicated matter, which is not made easier by the fact that there is no clear, simple definition of the term.
But secularism is a principle that is supposed to evolve with the times, legal scholars have stressed.
The French government has a website page dedicated to the question Qu'est-ce que la laïcité ? (What is secularism?).
Their long explanation can be summed up in four core principles, collected from a 2013 legal decision by the French Constitutional Council, the body in charge of reviewing constitutionality of French laws. These are:
- state neutrality;
- respect for all beliefs and equality of all citizens before the law without distinction of religion;
- freedom to worship;
- the absence of official worship.
What does that mean in practice?
Secularism in France is a principle meant to guarantee freedom for each individual to believe whatever they want and exercise this right as they please without interference from the state.
At the same time, religion must be exercised in the private, not public, sphere.
The state must be neutral, which means that public officials cannot wear religious signs. Crosses, hijabs, kippahs and other religious clothing or symbols are therefore banned from public institutions such as schools and for public officials on duty (teachers, police officers, firefighters).
There are also no displays of religion in public institutions, so schools do not have prayer meetings, religious assemblies or religious events such as Nativity Plays at Christmas.
Are there exceptions?
In France, there are nearly always exceptions to a rule. Despite its strict secularism, French public holidays still mark Christian holidays including Christmas, Easter and more obscure ones like Assumption and Ascension Day.
At the same time, far-right party Rassemblement National has not yet succeeded in its mission to decorate French town and city halls with Christian cribs at Christmas. That said, official buildings such as mairies do put up decorations at Christmas, usually some nice twinkly lights that are festive without being overtly Christian.
Secular laws do not, however, apply in quite the same way in the eastern borderlands of Alsace-Lorraine, where Christian and Jewish clerics are paid by the state, for historical reasons linked to wars with Germany.
READ MORE: EXPLAINED: Does France really have a hijab ban?
Is it changing in modern time?
French secularism has been on the defensive since the late 1980s with the emergence of identity politics, Christian and Jewish revivalism and most of all, radical Islam, given the movement of Muslims from its former colonies since the 1950s.
In 2004 France banned "the wearing of conspicuous religious symbols or garb" in state schools. It became known as "the French headscarf ban" abroad, though it applies to symbols of all religions.
In 2010 France banned the niqab, the full-face veil, in public places - although this law was eventually framed as a security concern and actually covers all full-face coverings. Several local authorities had attempted to ban the burkini, the full-cover swimsuit, on their beaches, but this was overturned by the courts.
What does it NOT mean?
Secularism is often misunderstood in France today, even by government officials. In September, a French MP of ruling party La République en Marche caused a stir when she refused to participate in a parliamentary session together with a Muslim woman who was wearing the headscarf.
1- Meanwhile in #France, the so-called color-blind nation: a French MP stormed out of an audition at the National Assembly because she found the presence of a Muslim woman wearing a Hijab unbearable and contrary to the values of the Republic. pic.twitter.com/EZcpOvQUMU
— Rim-Sarah Alouane (@RimSarah) September 17, 2020
While MPs and staff in public buildings in France are forbidden from wearing religious clothing, that rule does not apply to visitors, like the woman in question.
As a citizen and not a public official, she was exercising her right to religious freedom in accordance with French law cited above.
“The problem we are seeing today is that we want to impose neutrality on individuals, which is the opposite of laïcité," said Rim-Sarah Alouane, a French legal scholar and law Phd candidate who specialises in religious freedom, human rights and civil liberties in France, Europe and North America.Alouane told The Local she prefers not to translate laïcité to secularism, for accuracy purposes.
France's interior minister also caused uproar when he said supermarket chains should abolish their separate food aisles for ethnic foods. The comment, which was hailed by some rightwing commentators as a bold defence of secularism, caused critics to call out the interior minister as misusing the core principle to further his own political agenda.
As private businesses supermarkets - and all other stores - are not bound to observe laïcité in the same way as government agencies and public officials.
ANALYSIS: Why does France's interior minister think supermarket ethnic food isles are a threat to the nation?
Similarly, sports retailer Decathlon was attacked on the grounds of laïcité for offering a 'running hijab', although as a private business catering to private individuals it was perfectly entitled to offer the headgear.
“Interfering with religious matters in this way is in itself a violation of laïcité," Alouane said then.
"Laïcité is freedom."
Join the conversation in our comments section below. Share your own views and experience and if you have a question or suggestion for our journalists then email us at [email protected].
Please keep comments civil, constructive and on topic – and make sure to read our terms of use before getting involved.
Please log in here to leave a comment.