ANALYSIS: Why do migrants still leave northern France to head to UK?

AFP - [email protected]
ANALYSIS: Why do migrants still leave northern France to head to UK?
Migrants sit onboard a boat navigating the agitated waters of the English Channel off the coast of northern France, as they attempt to cross the maritime borders between France and the United Kingdom

Migrants who head to the United Kingdom often see it less as a panacea than a last-ditch means-to-an-end, according to Matthieu Tardis, an expert in migration policy at the French Institute of International Relations (IFRI).


Is the United Kingdom still an Eldorado for migrants who reach Calais in northern France?

"Some migrants in Calais have relatives or a community of fellow countrymen or women in the UK. Then there is the English language, which is much more widely spoken than French.

"But in the autumn of 2016, when the main camp was dismantled in Calais, we saw that when adults were offered housing and when we suspended the Dublin Regulation, a large majority stayed in France. They asked for asylum in France and many got it."

The EU's so-called Dublin Regulation stipulates migrants must apply for asylum in the European country where they first arrive - more often than not Italy, Greece and Spain - and will be sent back to that nation if found in another member state.

"The bad conditions they experience in France, in Italy, in other EU countries, pushes them to go even further, to think that in the UK it will be better.

"But often, they don't ask for asylum there as the Dublin Regulation is still valid, so they would be sent back elsewhere in the EU.

"They remain illegal. The economy is far less regulated than in France, there are more opportunities. It's a very liberal economy that needs labour that isn't that well paid, and foreigners typically accept these types of positions."


French police assist migrants, including five children and a baby, who tried to reach England by crossing the Channel and who were rescued off the French port city of Calais on May 16th.

Will the EU's Dublin asylum system be maintained despite Brexit?

"That will be a big issue that isn't about to be settled. The British submitted a proposal to the EU regarding a readmission mechanism that would allow them to continue as with Dublin. For the moment, the EU doesn't want to discuss that, it's quite a one-sided proposal.

"The UK is an island and rarely the first port of entry in Europe. In a way, the sea protects it, even if there are more and more crossings. 

"It is definitely easier for the British to negotiate with France on this issue rather than the EU, but it remains to be seen what France would gain from it.

"The British could also unilaterally decide that EU countries are safe third-party countries but if there is a bilateral convention with France, it will be easier for them."


A man watches the sunset as he stands by the beach in the town of Tardinghen, one of the beaches used by migrants in their attempt to cross the Channel illegally towards Britain on August 13th. Photo: AFP

So Brexit would have little impact on migrants wishing to cross over?

"It's in everyone's interest to cooperate to avoid tragedies. But in a way, the British have exported their borders onto French territory, like we Europeans do in North African countries or Turkey.

"France got British funding to secure the tunnel entrance, the port of Calais. Is France going to continue to negotiate in exchange for money? That's a possibility. That's been going on for 20 years, bilateral treaties have always played on that.

"What France should focus on is having legal ways for migrants to get to the United Kingdom. If there are as many crossing attempts, it's because policy only focuses on securing crossing points."

One such legal way could be family reunification.


Comments (1)

Join the conversation in our comments section below. Share your own views and experience and if you have a question or suggestion for our journalists then email us at [email protected].
Please keep comments civil, constructive and on topic – and make sure to read our terms of use before getting involved.

Please log in to leave a comment.

Anonymous 2020/09/17 09:38
Because most speak English and have friends or relations already there plus of course the handouts. It's not rocket science to work out.

See Also