INTERVIEW: What’s really behind the rising coronavirus rates in France?

After months of steady decrease, France’s coronavirus rates are on the rise. We asked the Director of the Geneva Institute, which monitors the pandemic across the world, about how worried we should be about the rise.

INTERVIEW: What's really behind the rising coronavirus rates in France?
France's coronavirus numbers are on the rise and health authorities have warned that the country easily could lose control of the virus. Photo: AFP

“All indicators show that transmission of SARS-COV-2 infection is progressing and intensifying in week 31,” France’s national health agency Santé Publique France wrote in their weekly Covid-19 update on Thursday.

France first reported a spike in the number new coronavirus cases a couple of weeks ago, when the country saw the daily reports exceed 1,000 for the first time in several months, a tally that kept high in the following days.

On Thursday last week, the number of intensive care patients admitted for Covid-19 rose for the first time since May. Although the increase was largely symbolic – by only one person, up to 345 – it marked a shift from the steady slump since April 9th when a peak of 7,019 patients was reached. The total number of intensive care patients as of August 6th was 360.

The rising numbers has had some people calling for more government action.

“So, how long are they going to watch the curve increase before reacting?” one person wrote in a Tweet that was shared nearly 1,000 times.



But some experts say there is no need to panic yet.

Antoine Flahault, professor of public health and Director of the Institute of Global Health at the University of Geneva, told The Local that, while there was “cause for worry,” the numbers needed to be put in context.

The Geneva Institute closely monitors the development of the pandemic across the world and Flahault compared the situation in France to that of other European countries, saying that at present the situation was “not alarming.”

“The virus has not disappeared during the summer, but France is not in a situation of exponential growth as back in March,” the professor said.

In March, the pandemic spread so quickly that hospitals in hot-spots were struggling to cope and the government sent in military personnel to help the hardest-hit areas.

France imposed one of the strictest nationwide lockdowns in the world, confining the entire population to their homes for two months.

Comparing the current pandemic state in France to that in March was like “taking a temperature with two different kinds of thermometers,” the professor said, as France's enhanced testing capacities made the metrics “much more sensitive now.”

“When you test more, you will get more cases,” Flahault said.

France has massively ramped up the country's testing capacities since this spring, to keep track of the virus and break up transmission chains. While the government's stated goal of 700,000 tests per day was yet to be met, France tested 580,000 people in the first week of August. This represented an increase from around 200,000-230,000 tests a week over the course of June, and up from around 400,000 tests per week in July.

The graphic below shows the number of tests done weekly since the end of lockdown in May.

Source: Santé Publique France

Health authorities have found the increase in new cases to be higher than expected relative to the country's current testing capacity.

At the same time, a majority of the new positives were so-called 'asymptomatic' cases of people who did not present visible signs of the virus. Fifty-one percent of the new cases last week were asymptomatic, down from 55 percent the week before. In total, 65 percent of the total positive confirmed cases in France have been ticked as asymptomatic.

“I’d rather speak about 'mild cases', because 'asymptomatic' is so hard to define,” Flahault, explaining that many of the people who were registered as asymptomatic would likely would experience some kind of symptoms in the days that followed the test.
Most of the asymptomatic cases are young, statistically more resilient people with a lower probability of falling severely ill from the virus, there was little way of knowing whether the current growth in new cases would result in a spike in the number of hospitalisations in the next couple of weeks, according to Flahault.
“It depends a lot of age distribution of the new cases,” he said
“If the new cases is mostly young people and there is no spillover to the elderly or retirement homes, we won’t see a rise to hospital numbers or death rates.”
Extensive testing would be crucial to prevent this kind of scenario, he said.

“The best policy today is to test a lot. That way you trigger the anxiety of the population and individual responsibility, which is the best way to control the disease,” he said.

“The worst-case scenario was what we saw this winter, when ill people went to the doctor who said, 'I can't do anything, we don't have any tests, go back home'.”
France has reached a testing capacity of about 580,000 tests per week. Photo: AFP

This seems to be the current official strategy.

The Scientific Council, set up to advise the government on coronavirus-related measures, this week released a warning that France risked losing control over the virus and that, if the numbers kept growing, the country soon could find itself in a situation similar to that of Spain.

“The young population understood that the risk for them was relatively low, but did not understand that they had to protect themselves to protect others,” said Jean-François Delfraissy, Head of the Scientific Council to France Inter the following day.
Delfraissy explained that the Council wanted to ensure transparency because the entire population, not just the government, played a role in ensuring that the virus did not again spiral out of control.
“Our concern is that we will see a significant return of the virus this autumn, when the weather changes,” Delfraissy said.

On Thursday, President Emmanuel Macron urged the French population to remain “at the highest level of vigilance,” and recommended that everyone “get used to wearing masks” also outdoors.

“When you can’t keep safe distances, put on a mask,” the president told BFMTV during a visit in Beirut, Lebanon.


An increasing number of local authorities have already enforced local rules on mask-wearing in some outdoor areas, piling on a nationwide rule of compulsory face-masks inside all public spaces.
The government has prepared for a scenario where hard-hit areas impose local lockdowns to curb the spread of the virus. 
“Localised lockdowns may be a useful tool when the situation seems to go out of control,” Flahault said, adding that: “The government is in a very difficult situation, there is no guidelines on when to choose a lockdown, be it at a local or national level.”
If France kept its testing capacities up to speed with the pandemic, there would not be a need for a new round of lockdown.
“When they pass the threshold of their testing capacities, they will have to introduce lockdown, that’s why they need to keep increasing it towards the autumn,” he said.
“France should not clamp down a new nationwide lockdown now.”

Member comments

  1. Pres. Macron recognizes the importance of mask-weearing even outdoors but does not require it. What’s the sense in that? It’s the most cavalier in society who are the greatest risk of igniting the second wave and who need to be told that they “must” wear masks (on pain of fine) rather than they “should” wear masks.

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.


‘Public opinion is ready’ – These French senators want to legalise marijuana

A group of 31 French senators of the Socialist, Green and Republican parties have come together to write a statement calling for the legalisation of marijuana in France.

'Public opinion is ready' - These French senators want to legalise marijuana

France is known for having some of the strictest laws regarding marijuana consumption in Europe – while simultaneously maintaining one of the highest rates of cannabis usage in the EU. 

A group of French senators – coming from the Socialist, Green and centre-right Les Républicains parties – are trying to change those laws, and have come together to call for marijuana to be legalised in France.

The group of 31 co-signed a statement published in French newspaper, Le Monde, on Wednesday, August 10th.

In the statement, the senators promised to launch a ‘consultation process’ to submit a bill to legalise marijuana “in the coming months.”

The proposition was headed by Senator Gilbert-Luc Devinaz, a member of the Socialist Party, and gained support from the party’s leader, Patrick Kanner.

READ MORE: The long and winding road towards changing France’s cannabis laws

A report by the Assemblé Nationale, which was published in May 2021, estimated that nearly 18 million French people (more than 25 percent of the population) had already consumed marijuana, and that an additional 1.5 million consume it regularly.

This, coupled with the 2019 finding that nearly one in two French people (45 percent) said they were in favour of legalisation, according to a survey by the French Observatory of Drugs and Drug Addiction (OFDT), helped strengthen the senators’ position.

“Public opinion is ready, the legislature must act,” they wrote.

Their senators argue that legalising marijuana in France will allow the authorities to better protect French citizens, saying that legalising would not require “minimising the health impacts of cannabis consumption” but rather would allow regulation similar to “public policies for tobacco, alcohol or gambling.”

For the group of 31 senators, the benefits of legalisation would involve a better control over the “health quality of products consumed,” “curbing trafficking in disadvantaged areas,” developing large-scale prevention plans,” and finally the taxation of cannabis products and redirection of law enforcement resources. Decriminalisation – in their opinion – would not be sufficient as this would simply “deprive authorities the ability to act,” in contrast to legalisation. 

READ MORE: Is France moving towards legalising cannabis for recreational purposes?

“In the long term, new tax revenues would be generated from the cannabis trade and from savings in the justice and police sectors”, which would make it possible to mobilize “significant resources for prevention as well as for rehabilitation and economic development,” wrote the senators.

In France, the conversation around cannabis has evolved in recent years – former Health Minister (and current government spokesman) Olivier Véran said to France Bleu in September 2021 that “countries that have gone towards legalisation have results better than those of France in the last ten years,” adding that he was interested in the potential therapeutic use of cannabis.

Currently, the drug is illegal in France. Previously, it fell under a 1970-law of illicit drug use, making it punishable with up to a year prison and an up to €3,750 fine.

However, in 2020, the government softened the penalties, making it possible for those caught consuming it to opt for an on-the-spot fine of €200.

There is also an ongoing trial involving 3,000 patients to test the impacts of medical marijuana usage, particularly with regard to pain relief.