ANALYSIS: Why coronavirus could cause an outbreak of very nasty politics in France

We are all fighting ‘flu now and some of us are fighting it better than others. This is true of governments as well as individuals, writes John Lichfield.

ANALYSIS: Why coronavirus could cause an outbreak of very nasty politics in France
The health crisis could well lead to a political crisis. Photo: AFP

The initial politics of Covid-19 (yes, I know that it’s not quite the same as influenza) are the politics of look-what-the-neighbours-are-doing.  They may yet become something much nastier.

Many people in Britain, especially pro-Europeans, say that Emmanuel Macron reacted quicker and better than Boris Johnson. Many people in France, especially opponents of Emmanuel Macron, believe that the President was slow and evasive and made some incomprehensible choices.

For the latest on the situation in France, click here.

Was Macron too slow to impose a lockdown on France? Photo: AFP

Everyone thinks that Germany is getting it right, without being able to say what exactly they got right (not even the Germans). Everyone thinks that Spain’s reaction went seriously astray, without being able clearly to identify why.

Everyone thought that the Italians over-reacted two weeks ago. Now many people accept that the Italians got it right but may have been a little slow off the mark.

Many people criticised the scattered and selfish initial European Union responses. They may not have noticed that the EU is, belatedly, getting some things right. Germany is taking an overspill of French patients; a multi-billion Euros joint EU economic rescue programme is under discussion.

Everyone in Europe (and not just Europe) thinks that Donald Trump has performed disgracefully for weeks. Now, finally, Trump seems to have grasped that Coronovirus cannot be defeated, or exploited, with lies, bluster and appeals to racism.

Opinion polls in all countries have shown an immediate “crisis dividend” for governments. Macron has zoomed in the approval ratings by 13 points to 51 percent  – his highest for two years.

This will not last. After less than a week of confinement, public patience in France is already wearing thin. Opposition politicians are looking for opportunities to pounce.

Anger is growing – towards wealthy people who fled to their second homes; or towards multi-racial suburbs of French cities where the lock-down has been defied by a fringe of young people who consider themselves beyond the law.

There are reasons enough to criticise our leaders. There are also good reasons to support and sympathise with them as they fight a crushing, invisible enemy with faltering enthusiasm from their front line troops.

By front-line troops, I do not mean the heroic doctors and nurses who are risking their own lives, sometimes without adequate protection. 

I mean the rest of us. We have the prime responsibility to fight the greatest and scariest enemy of our lifetimes by doing what many find to be the hardest thing of all – nothing.

READ ALSO These are the rules of lockdown in France

Not everyone has been following the 'stay home' advice. Photo: AFP


Consider how agonising are the decisions which have confronted all our governments in the last month. Emmanuel Macron tried desperately to avoid the Italian doomsday solution of complete lockdown. He probably waited a few days too long.

He finally took the decision to close down large parts of the fifth largest western economy and place 60,000,000 people under house arrest (essential workers apart).

He came up with a vast state-funded economic programme which is intended to keep businesses afloat until the crisis passes.

The man elected to roll back the French state has imposed a programme of state control and de facto nationalisation which would have made Franklin D Roosevelt jealous and brought a smile to the lips of Joseph Stalin.

No business will be allowed to go bust. The state will fund generous unemployment pay for this laid off temporarily. Taxes and charges on all business will be suspended.

There is a bailout fund for freelances and owners of small companies. The state will guarantee €300bn of loans for bigger businesses.

In Britain, the Johnson government blustered and blathered but finally came up last Friday with an economic programme which looked remarkably similar to Macron’s (help for small businesses and freelances apart).

It may in the next couple of days be forced to follow France in imposing a legally enforceable lockdown.

Johnson is reported to believe that such things – state-enforced quarantine, written permission to go to the shops, fines – are fundamentally unBritish.

He believes that they cannot easily be imposed on the nation of Magna Carta and Habeas Corpus. As we are discovering, they cannot easily be imposed on any country.

Even those voluntary restrictions which are in force in Britain, such as closure of pubs and restaurants, followed a frank telephone call from Macron last week.

Unless Britain imposed more social distancing to slow the advance of Covid19, France would close the tunnel and Channel Ports – to trade not just people.

Johnson has got many things wrong. But Macron’s initial approach was also culpably passive  – and in some respects still is.

Why is France still testing so little for Covid19, less even than the UK?

READ ALSO Coronavirus testing in France – how does it work and who gets tested?

Health minister Olivier Véran says that testing the sickest is the priority. Photo: AFP

The official policy is that tests are rationed for the elderly, the pregnant, those with underlying health problems and pregnant women.

This runs counter to World Health Organisation advice.

Several explanations have been given. They include a lack of lab capacity in France and the pointlessness of general testing once the virus is known to be running amok.

The mystery remains.

As a result the daily bulletins on the advance of the virus  from the French government have to be read with caution. (The nightly announcements have become a grim kind of sports results, in the absence of sports.)

Officially, there are 16,018 known cases of Covid19 in France. The health minister Olivier Véran admits that true figure may be 90,000 – but that’s just a guess.

The only reliable running scores, therefore, are for the “gravely ill” (1,746 on Sunday night) and deaths (674). Both are advancing rapidly.

They are not – yet – exploding in the way that they did in Italy and now Spain.

The next few days will be crucial. An extension of the 15 day lock-down is, in any case, inevitable. If it seems the progress of the virus is being contained in France, it may be possible to imagine a return to something like normal life by May or June.

If the French figures for the dead and gravely ill spin out of control, we’re all facing a long sentence.

Deep anxiety and boredom are a toxic combination. Add dotty theories and simplistic solutions on social media. I fear that the politics of Covid19 may yet turn very nasty indeed.









Member comments

  1. I penned this observation at the time of Macron’s emergence onto the political stage;

    “Generalisation on my part.
    Those who once really cared (born into post- war hard times) are now grown old. Many of us did surprisingly well as a result of the caring structures of our formative times. We were quite lucky in some respects.
    Yet, we still utter and hear the phrase; “… in my day we had to… , blah, blah, blah…. . We’ve come to care less than we once did.
    Meanwhile, the new generation have been born into this less caring world. They joined the game hearing, and thus believing, “there’s no such thing as society.” This philosophy has made them selfish and indifferent to those less fortunate; until now.
    The only way today’s majority, middle populace, knows to secure or maintain their own social position is to diminish those who have less. They do this by not caring about or demeaning the impoverished, the unemployed, or the immigrant.
    We are a divided people in so many ways: not caring is but one manifestation of this division.
    We do need to take a long hard look at ourselves but we, also, need a new political way, new thinking, new expectations.
    “En Marche” may not appeal to our lost and deluded country, but it should, at least, be considered.”

    Precient perhaps?

  2. I should add; I was living in the UK at the time of this observation; in the thick of the appalling Brexit meltdown.
    Fortunately, I now live in France.
    Stay safe.

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.


French lawmakers push for abortion rights to be enshrined in constitution

After the seismic decision of the US Supreme Court on Friday, French MPs are calling for the right to abortion in France to be protected by the constitution.

French lawmakers push for abortion rights to be enshrined in constitution

Lawmakers from French President Emmanuel Macron’s Renaissance party are to propose a parliamentary bill on Saturday that would enshrine the right to abortion in the constitution. 

The move comes after the US Supreme Court overturned the landmark 1973 “Roe v. Wade” decision on Friday.

“In France we guarantee and advance the rights of women. We protect them,” said Aurore Bergé – the head of Renaissance in the Assemblée nationale and one of the key sponsors of the bill. 

Another co-sponsor, Marie-Pierre Rixain tweeted: “What happens in elsewhere cannot happen in France. We must protect the right to abortion for future generations. 

In 2018 and 2019, Emmanuel Macron’s party – which back then was known as La République en Marche – refused to back bills proposed by left-wing party, La France Insoumise, to enshrine abortion rights into the constitution. 

In a Saturday interview with France Inter, Bergé suggested that the success of Marine Le Pen’s Rassemblement National during parliamentary elections earlier this month had created a sense of newfound urgency. 

She described the far-right MPs as “fierce opponents of women’s access to abortion” and said it was important “to take no risk” in securing it. 

READ MORE France’s Macron condemns US abortion ruling

French Prime Minister Elisabeth Borne has come out in support of the bill. 

The left-wing opposition block, NUPES, also backs it and had planned to propose an identical piece legislation of its own on Monday. 

Macron is seeking parliamentary allies to pass reforms after his formation lost its majority in legislative elections earlier this month.

The legal timeframe to terminate a pregnancy in France was extended from 12 to 14 weeks in the last legislature.

Changing the constitution requires the National Assembly and Senate to adopt the same text, then a three-fifths majority of parliament sitting in congress. The other option is a referendum.