Outrage over videos of French police clashing with women on feminist march
France's equalities minister has demanded an investigation after videos circulated online showing police tear gassing and attacking women on a feminist march.
Footage appearing to show of police officers using tear gas and violently detaining women taking part in late-night feminist march in Paris on Saturday, March 7th has caused outrage in France.
In one video, published around 11pm, a group of police officers was seen running towards protesters, hitting them with batons and throwing some of them on the ground.
Interpellation musclée des forces de l’ordre vers les féministes!!#MarcheFéministe #Paris pic.twitter.com/ImzUzpLpzF
— Amar Taoualit (@TaoualitAmar) March 7, 2020
Other videos showed women crying from tear gas.
Des tirs de lacrymogènes lancés par la police vers les féministes!!#MarcheFéministe pic.twitter.com/EckuqNyBIj
— Amar Taoualit (@TaoualitAmar) March 7, 2020
The "symbolic nocturnal march" was organised to depart at 8pm in central Paris as a precursor to the big protest planned for the celebration of international women’s day the following day, March 8th.
The incidents occurred as police tried to disperse the protesters after the march was due to finish at 10pm.
Author and filmmaker David Dufresne tweeted at 11pm on Saturday that protesters were being “forced into the Metro” in central Paris.
allo @Place_Beauvau - c'est pour un signalement - 888
Manifestants #MarcheFéministe amenés de force dans le métro
Station République, Paris, 7 mars 2020, source et images: @HZ_Press pic.twitter.com/uzv8P0QZud
— David Dufresne (@davduf) March 8, 2020
Activists condemned the police's actions.
Caroline de Haas, of the French feminist collective Nous Toutes, tweeted: “Last night, feminists were beaten by police forces as they were protesting - notably - sexual violence. [President] Emmanuel Macron, [Interior Minister] Christophe Castanter, [gender equality minister] Marlène Schiappa, how could you give these kinds of instructions?”
Hier soir, des féministes ont été frappées par les forces de l’ordre alors qu’elles manifestaient - notamment - contre les violences sexuelles.@EmmanuelMacron, @CCastaner, @MarleneSchiappa, comment avez-vous pu donner des consignes pareilles ?#marchefeministe
— Caroline De Haas (@carolinedehaas) March 8, 2020
Charge policière vers le cortège féministe à République. Les femmes résistent en repoussant les boucliers des forces de l’ordre. pic.twitter.com/yeEI4k8EHU
— Remy Buisine (@RemyBuisine) March 7, 2020
une nasse lors d’une manifestation féministe pacifique :
à quel moment est-ce justifié?#republique #8mars #NousToutes pic.twitter.com/bVUymvvzPK
— Marceline Samion (@MarcelineSamion) March 7, 2020
The following day, French politicians condemned the police for a disproportionate use of force.
Paris Mayor Anne Hidalgo said she was “shocked by the unacceptable and incomprehensible violence” and that she “supported the female and male protesters.”
Choquée par les violences inadmissibles et incompréhensibles la nuit dernière place de la République. Soutien aux manifestantes et manifestants. #8Mars #MarcheFeministe
— Anne Hidalgo (@Anne_Hidalgo) March 8, 2020
French gender equality minister Marlène Schiappa also publicly condemned the police officers' actions.
“All women must be able to peacefully protest to make their rights respected!” she tweeted, stating that interior minister Christophe Castaner had asked the Paris police department to file a report about Saturday's incidents.
Toutes les femmes doivent pouvoir manifester pacifiquement pour faire respecter leurs droits !
Le ministre @CCastaner a demandé un rapport à la Préfecture de Police sur ce qui s’est passé en marge de la #marcheféministe
— ?? MarleneSchiappa (@MarleneSchiappa) March 8, 2020
Publicly condemning police officers is not something the French government does lightly or often, and Schiappa later walked back on her criticism, telling French TV that the reason for the violence had been that the “course of the protest was not respected."
France has become used to seeing images of clashes between police and protesters since the 'yellow vest' social movement made it a mission to film and upload violent incidents online.
Earlier this year, scenes of police and firefighters fighting on the streets of the capital caught international attention.
READ MORE: How the 'yellow vests' made France have a national conversation about police violence
Gender equality minister Marlène Schiappa said all women have the right to protest to have their rights heard following the clashes with police on Saturday. Photo: AFP
But the police said their use of force was merited, as the protesters had remained on the streets even after the march was set to end.
In a press statement published on Sunday, March 8th, the Paris police said that groups of protesters had "intentionally disrespected" police orders, resulting in the "police having to use tear gas and push the protesters back."
Le rapport demandé @prefpolice par @CCastaner selon l'annonce @MarleneSchiappa ce matin est tombé (ou presque). Le voici: les «personnes récalcitrantes» projetées violemment dans le métro l'ont été pour avoir «opposé une résistance physique»
Source: https://t.co/jdVB6g63J7 pic.twitter.com/2YyhrWw0xx
— David Dufresne (@davduf) March 8, 2020
Nine people were arrested during the protests, according to the police.
READ ALSO ANALYSIS: French police are not all thugs - they are being placed in an impossible situation
Femen feminist group protesters made a comparison with the coronavirus and the 'virus of patricarchy' in Paris on March 8th. Photo: AFP
The following day, International Women's Day, saw tens of thousands of people in Paris join a demonstration which passed off peacefully, although with some reports of the police firing off tear gas in the afternoon.
However there was violence at an official event in Nantes in the afternoon. Participants at the feminist march told French press that the police had fired off tear gas grenades into the group of protesters, despite children being present.
Nantes : quand la police gaze totalement gratuitement la manifestation féministe du 8 mars.
---
Images : N1n1psyko, Nicolas Mollé, Perer Allan, Attac 44, Transition Cube, Chloé Beulin. pic.twitter.com/MU7lR5kpg9
— Nantes Révoltée (@Nantes_Revoltee) March 9, 2020
"My girl nearly got hit in the head by a [tear gas] grenade," one woman told France 3.
Bonsoir @MarleneSchiappa et @CCastaner,
Avez-vous une réaction ou un commentaire justifiant ce jet de lacrymo sur des femmes (et des enfants...) dansant et chantant pacifiquement à #Nantes?
Y’a t’il eu provocation ou outrage aux forces de l’ordre? #8Mars https://t.co/kSRUsNLmrg pic.twitter.com/ERpIHjY5LH
— Elodie Jauneau (@ElodieJauneau) March 8, 2020
Police fire teargas into an International Women's Day march in Nantes. https://t.co/OwyvScwELo
— Kim Willsher (@kimwillsher1) March 9, 2020
Comments
See Also
Footage appearing to show of police officers using tear gas and violently detaining women taking part in late-night feminist march in Paris on Saturday, March 7th has caused outrage in France.
In one video, published around 11pm, a group of police officers was seen running towards protesters, hitting them with batons and throwing some of them on the ground.
Interpellation musclée des forces de l’ordre vers les féministes!!#MarcheFéministe #Paris pic.twitter.com/ImzUzpLpzF
— Amar Taoualit (@TaoualitAmar) March 7, 2020
Other videos showed women crying from tear gas.
Des tirs de lacrymogènes lancés par la police vers les féministes!!#MarcheFéministe pic.twitter.com/EckuqNyBIj
— Amar Taoualit (@TaoualitAmar) March 7, 2020
The "symbolic nocturnal march" was organised to depart at 8pm in central Paris as a precursor to the big protest planned for the celebration of international women’s day the following day, March 8th.
The incidents occurred as police tried to disperse the protesters after the march was due to finish at 10pm.
Author and filmmaker David Dufresne tweeted at 11pm on Saturday that protesters were being “forced into the Metro” in central Paris.
allo @Place_Beauvau - c'est pour un signalement - 888
— David Dufresne (@davduf) March 8, 2020
Manifestants #MarcheFéministe amenés de force dans le métro
Station République, Paris, 7 mars 2020, source et images: @HZ_Press pic.twitter.com/uzv8P0QZud
Activists condemned the police's actions.
Caroline de Haas, of the French feminist collective Nous Toutes, tweeted: “Last night, feminists were beaten by police forces as they were protesting - notably - sexual violence. [President] Emmanuel Macron, [Interior Minister] Christophe Castanter, [gender equality minister] Marlène Schiappa, how could you give these kinds of instructions?”
Hier soir, des féministes ont été frappées par les forces de l’ordre alors qu’elles manifestaient - notamment - contre les violences sexuelles.@EmmanuelMacron, @CCastaner, @MarleneSchiappa, comment avez-vous pu donner des consignes pareilles ?#marchefeministe
— Caroline De Haas (@carolinedehaas) March 8, 2020
Charge policière vers le cortège féministe à République. Les femmes résistent en repoussant les boucliers des forces de l’ordre. pic.twitter.com/yeEI4k8EHU
— Remy Buisine (@RemyBuisine) March 7, 2020
une nasse lors d’une manifestation féministe pacifique :
— Marceline Samion (@MarcelineSamion) March 7, 2020
à quel moment est-ce justifié?#republique #8mars #NousToutes pic.twitter.com/bVUymvvzPK
The following day, French politicians condemned the police for a disproportionate use of force.
Paris Mayor Anne Hidalgo said she was “shocked by the unacceptable and incomprehensible violence” and that she “supported the female and male protesters.”
Choquée par les violences inadmissibles et incompréhensibles la nuit dernière place de la République. Soutien aux manifestantes et manifestants. #8Mars #MarcheFeministe
— Anne Hidalgo (@Anne_Hidalgo) March 8, 2020
French gender equality minister Marlène Schiappa also publicly condemned the police officers' actions.
“All women must be able to peacefully protest to make their rights respected!” she tweeted, stating that interior minister Christophe Castaner had asked the Paris police department to file a report about Saturday's incidents.
Toutes les femmes doivent pouvoir manifester pacifiquement pour faire respecter leurs droits !
— ?? MarleneSchiappa (@MarleneSchiappa) March 8, 2020
Le ministre @CCastaner a demandé un rapport à la Préfecture de Police sur ce qui s’est passé en marge de la #marcheféministe
Publicly condemning police officers is not something the French government does lightly or often, and Schiappa later walked back on her criticism, telling French TV that the reason for the violence had been that the “course of the protest was not respected."
France has become used to seeing images of clashes between police and protesters since the 'yellow vest' social movement made it a mission to film and upload violent incidents online.
Earlier this year, scenes of police and firefighters fighting on the streets of the capital caught international attention.
READ MORE: How the 'yellow vests' made France have a national conversation about police violence
Gender equality minister Marlène Schiappa said all women have the right to protest to have their rights heard following the clashes with police on Saturday. Photo: AFP
But the police said their use of force was merited, as the protesters had remained on the streets even after the march was set to end.
In a press statement published on Sunday, March 8th, the Paris police said that groups of protesters had "intentionally disrespected" police orders, resulting in the "police having to use tear gas and push the protesters back."
Le rapport demandé @prefpolice par @CCastaner selon l'annonce @MarleneSchiappa ce matin est tombé (ou presque). Le voici: les «personnes récalcitrantes» projetées violemment dans le métro l'ont été pour avoir «opposé une résistance physique»
— David Dufresne (@davduf) March 8, 2020
Source: https://t.co/jdVB6g63J7 pic.twitter.com/2YyhrWw0xx
Nine people were arrested during the protests, according to the police.
READ ALSO ANALYSIS: French police are not all thugs - they are being placed in an impossible situation
Femen feminist group protesters made a comparison with the coronavirus and the 'virus of patricarchy' in Paris on March 8th. Photo: AFP
The following day, International Women's Day, saw tens of thousands of people in Paris join a demonstration which passed off peacefully, although with some reports of the police firing off tear gas in the afternoon.
However there was violence at an official event in Nantes in the afternoon. Participants at the feminist march told French press that the police had fired off tear gas grenades into the group of protesters, despite children being present.
Nantes : quand la police gaze totalement gratuitement la manifestation féministe du 8 mars.
— Nantes Révoltée (@Nantes_Revoltee) March 9, 2020
---
Images : N1n1psyko, Nicolas Mollé, Perer Allan, Attac 44, Transition Cube, Chloé Beulin. pic.twitter.com/MU7lR5kpg9
"My girl nearly got hit in the head by a [tear gas] grenade," one woman told France 3.
Bonsoir @MarleneSchiappa et @CCastaner,
— Elodie Jauneau (@ElodieJauneau) March 8, 2020
Avez-vous une réaction ou un commentaire justifiant ce jet de lacrymo sur des femmes (et des enfants...) dansant et chantant pacifiquement à #Nantes?
Y’a t’il eu provocation ou outrage aux forces de l’ordre? #8Mars https://t.co/kSRUsNLmrg pic.twitter.com/ERpIHjY5LH
Police fire teargas into an International Women's Day march in Nantes. https://t.co/OwyvScwELo
— Kim Willsher (@kimwillsher1) March 9, 2020
Join the conversation in our comments section below. Share your own views and experience and if you have a question or suggestion for our journalists then email us at [email protected].
Please keep comments civil, constructive and on topic – and make sure to read our terms of use before getting involved.
Please log in here to leave a comment.