Why did a group of French farmers demolish a McDonald’s?

It's 20 years since a group of French farmers dismantled a partially built McDonald's restaurant in southern France, but what was their protest about and what happened afterwards?

Why did a group of French farmers demolish a McDonald's?
Support for the farmers' protests over US beef with high hormone levels. Photo: AFP

So what happened?

In August 1999, a group of five farmers who were members of the local farming union went to a partially built new McDonald's in the south west town of Millau, in Aveyron, and tore it down.

They announced the event beforehand at a press conference and invited people along to watch, and also held a Roquefort-tasting as the demolition got under way.

They caused €120,000 worth of damage and the five were tried in the criminal court in Millau later in the year. Four of them were given suspended sentences but the ringleader, José Bové, was jailed for three months.

José Bové, right, and his co-accused in court in Millau. Photo: AFP

Why did they do it?

Well the protest was really aimed at America, of which McDonald's is always a handy symbol. At that time, the US and the EU were involved in a fight over imports and tariffs (which may sound familiar to readers today).

Essentially the EU was refusing to allow imports of American beef because the high levels of hormones used in farming in the US meant that the meat didn't meet EU food standards. America responded by imposing punitive tariffs on European products including cheeses made from raw sheep's milk such as Roquefort – which is where the Millau farmers come in as the region is a major producer of both milk and cheese.

Thousands protested across France, demanding that Bové be released from prison. Photo: AFP

What happened next?

The case rapidly became a cause celèbre in France and José Bové was seen as a martyr for people standing up for environmental concerns. The case came a a time when there were a lot of worries around genetically modified food in general, and many environmental activists took up his cause. There were demonstrations around the country demanding that he be freed, and many others McDonald's sites saw protests and pickets outside.

After his release Bové, who had been an activist as well as a farmer long before the Millau demolition, became more involved in politics and in 2009 was elected as an MEP as a member of the Green party.

José Bové later became an MEP. Photo: AFP

And what about the tariffs?

Well anyone who follows the news will know that threatening tariffs is a favourite measure of the current US president who has repeatedly threatened to slap extra tariffs on French goods including Roquefort, seafood and wine in retaliation for initiatives from the French government such as a tax on internet giants.

French farmers are still concerned about the import of foreign food stuffs, with current union leaders citing worries about the Ceta (EU-Canada) and Mercosur (with several South American countries) trade agreements, which France has signed but not yet ratified.

Nicolas Girod, national spokesman for the Confédération paysanne et producteur de lait (farmers and milk producers union) in the Jura region, has promised a “hot autumn” of protests against them, including at the G7 summit in Biarritz at the end of August.

The McDonald's in Millau was later rebuilt and remains open today.

After the Millau protest, however, McDonald's did introduce a pledge to use more local ingredients in their restaurants, so if you think your Big Mac tastes better in France, it could be because it's made with locally sourced beef.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.


French hunter kills bear that bit him

A 70-year-old hunter killed a bear in southwest France Saturday after it attacked and seriously wounded him, local officials said.

A brown bear is pictured in the semi-wildlife animal park of Les Angles, southwestern France.
Brown bears had nearly disappeared in France until the country began a reintroduction programme, importing them from Slovenia. AFP PHOTO / RAYMOND ROIG

The female bear, who was travelling with her cubs, bit him as he was hunting in the Seix region of Ariege, a source close to the case said.

Rescued by the local gendarmerie, he was transported to the intensive care unit of a hospital in Toulouse with a wound to his leg at the level of his femoral artery, officials at the prefecture in Ariege said.

One source close to the case said he was in a serious condition.

The hunter told local officials he had been out with a group of other hunters on the trail of a boar, when the female bear, who was travelling with her cubs, attacked him.

After being wounded, the hunter shot the bear twice, killing it.

The local gendarme unit was called out to rescue him at around 3:30 pm (1430 GMT). They discovered the body of the bear a few metres from where they had found the hunter.

An investigation has been opened into the incident, the prefecture in Ariege said.

One local official told AFP on Saturday: “This is really what we feared.”

“Today, you can really see that cohabitation is complicated,” said Christine Tequi, president of the Ariege department council.

The brown bear had nearly disappeared in this part of the world when France began a programme of reintroducing them, importing them from Slovenia.

Today, there are around sixty of them in the Pyrenees range, leading to increasing tensions with local farmers, because of the threat they pose to their livestock.

In 2020, three bears were illegally killed in the Pyrenees: two of them in Spain and one in France. The French government has committed to replacing any bear killed by a man.

READ ALSO: The decades-old battle between French farmers and conservationists over bears
READ ALSO: What are the most dangerous animals in France?