On Monday evening, the French Senate approved the government's Notre-Dame restoration bill – but added a clause that it must be restored to the state it was before the blaze, striking a blow to the government which had launched an international architecture competition to debate ideas on the restoration.
The subject of the rebuilding of the cathedral – which was left badly damaged after fire tore through the roof and destroyed the spire on April 15 – has become a fraught battleground between traditionalists who want an exact restoration and others who favour a more imaginative take.
Some of the suggestions have included a rooftop garden, an 'endless spire' of light and a swimming pool on top of the building.
READ ALSO
- Should France break historic building rules so Notre-Dame can be restored in five years?
- IN PICTURES: Seven amazing ideas for the restoration of Notre-Dame
- Fancy taking a dip in a Paris pool on the roof of Notre-Dame
The Senate has now approved the restoration bill already passed by the French parliament to allow work on the structure to be completed in time for the Paris Olympics in 2024 – but requires that the restoration be faithful to the “last known visual state” of the cathedral, in an attempt to check the government, which has launched an international architectural competition soliciting designs for renovation.
The question of whether Notre-Dame will be restored identically has become a political battleground. French president Emmanuel Macron has called for “an inventive reconstruction”, while Paris' Socialist mayor Anne Hidalgo favors an identical restoration and called herself “conservative” on the subject.
La cathédrale #NotreDame est une œuvre qui appartient à tous les Parisiens, à tous les Français et au monde entier. Je suis favorable à une restauration à l’identique, fondée sur les savoir-faire ancestraux des compagnons du devoir et du tour de France. https://t.co/xlmKcJhVX2
— Anne Hidalgo (@Anne_Hidalgo) May 27, 2019
Senators also removed a controversial clause from the law which would give the government the power to override regulations on planning, environmental and heritage protection and public tenders. Many members of the Senate, dominated by the right-wing opposition, have been especially critical of President’s Macron’s promise to finish reconstruction within five years.
The law would enable the government to create an établissement public à caractère administratif (EPA), or public project, to oversee the reconstruction project. This EPA would itself be placed under the authority of the Ministry of Culture, currently directed by Franck Riester.
L'incendie de Notre-Dame de Paris a entraîné une mobilisation populaire sans précédent. Des centaines de milliers de dons ont afflué de France et du monde entier. Alors, il fallait un cadre pour les accueillir. C'est tout l'objet de ce projet de loi. #PJLNotreDame #DirectSénat pic.twitter.com/JTYOD47aq5
— Franck Riester (@franckriester) May 27, 2019
Another minor modification is the backdating of a proposed tax break for those who have made donations for the cathedral’s reconstruction.
The bill approved by the Assemblée nationale outlines a national subscription project to be put in place in order to manage funds collected, making donations made from April 16th through December 31st eligible for a deduction of 75 percent, up to €1,000. The Senate has pushed the beginning of this period back to April 15th, so that those who made the earliest donations will not be penalised.
Because of the changes imposed, the bill cannot now pass directly in to law, so the Senate and the Assemblée nationale will now attempt to come to an agreement on a version of the bill that will become law.
Notre Dame is a place of Christian worship. It should not be made vulgar by swimming pools and laser lights. There are other places for those. The ancient and beautiful building should be restored as much as possible to the original.
How does the Roman Catholic Church fit into this restoration struggle? Do they not have any say? It is their church, and it is a very active parish also. Do their needs mean anything? I understand your need for patrimony and preservation. But this is a church, albeit a very famous one.