Victory for British neighbours in €57 million chateau court battle
The Local France - [email protected]
Published: 26 Mar, 2019 CET.
Updated: Tue 26 Mar 2019 10:49 CET
A vast Renaissance-style castle in southern France, worth €57 million, has been ordered to be demolished in a long-running judicial battle between a French property
developer and his multi-millionaire British neighbours.
It's not exactly something you'd want to be told if you owned your very own castle in a picturesque part of France.
But the Aix-en-Provence court of appeal ruled on Monday that Château Diter in Grasse, a town on the French Riviera, has to be destroyed on legal grounds.
And the owner of the €57 million property, Patrick Diter, has been given a year and a half to do it.
So, what's going on?
Well, the property wasn't always the vast French chateau of 3,000 metres squared that it is now.
Destruction?
Cette villa toscane est certes construite sans permis; n'est-il pas plutôt possible d'en dessaisir le propriétaire ?
On voit tellement d'horreurs sans permis de construire, pour une fois que c'est beau...#ChateauDiter@ltdla@bernstephane pic.twitter.com/J3w2Nm2dLD
— Louis-Alexandre Alciator (@AlciatorLA) March 26, 2019
In fact, at one point, it was a more modest 200 metres squared country house which through a lot of construction work, Diter turned into the palace it is today.
The chateau has a swimming pool, a heliport and a road of 600 metres squared - all built illegally in a protected wooded area.
Due to the fact that the work was carried out illegally, the French courts ordered "the restoration of the premises by demolishing all of the construction work" which had been carried out since 2005.
Dans les Alpes-Maritimes, la justice ordonne la destruction du « château Diter », un palais estimé à 57 millions d'euros https://t.co/L7NrTu5YQT
— Le Parisien (@le_Parisien) March 26, 2019
Diter who was also fined €450,000 will face a further fine of €500 for every day he exceeds the time limit of 18 months specified by the French courts.
Diter was also ordered to pay his neighbours €450,000 in damages, but an earlier imposed six-month suspended jail sentence was waived on appeal.
At Diter's first trial, held back in January 2019, assistant public prosecutor Pierre-Jean Gaury described Diter's transformation of the property as a "pharaonic project, delusional, totally illegal and built illegally."
Gaury added that it was carried out "in violation of urban planning rules, as well as of safety and environmental rules" by an owner whose "only concern is money".
Diter had earlier acknowledged making "mistakes" in carrying out wave after wave of expansion to the farmhouse on the large property he acquired in 1999.
He later sold off part of the estate to a London-based British couple, Stephen and Caroline Butt.
Stephen Butt operates Silchester Partners, an asset management company, and was described by the Sunday Times newspaper as one of the richest fund managers in England.
Over 10 years, he and his wife filed a series of complaints over what they called their neighbour's "building frenzy" and the disturbance caused when the property is let out for large-scale weddings and film shoots.
The property notably featured as Villa Carmella in the first season of Riviera, a TV thriller first broadcast by Sky Atlantic.
Comments
See Also
It's not exactly something you'd want to be told if you owned your very own castle in a picturesque part of France.
But the Aix-en-Provence court of appeal ruled on Monday that Château Diter in Grasse, a town on the French Riviera, has to be destroyed on legal grounds.
And the owner of the €57 million property, Patrick Diter, has been given a year and a half to do it.
So, what's going on?
Well, the property wasn't always the vast French chateau of 3,000 metres squared that it is now.
Destruction?
— Louis-Alexandre Alciator (@AlciatorLA) March 26, 2019
Cette villa toscane est certes construite sans permis; n'est-il pas plutôt possible d'en dessaisir le propriétaire ?
On voit tellement d'horreurs sans permis de construire, pour une fois que c'est beau...#ChateauDiter@ltdla@bernstephane pic.twitter.com/J3w2Nm2dLD
In fact, at one point, it was a more modest 200 metres squared country house which through a lot of construction work, Diter turned into the palace it is today.
The chateau has a swimming pool, a heliport and a road of 600 metres squared - all built illegally in a protected wooded area.
Due to the fact that the work was carried out illegally, the French courts ordered "the restoration of the premises by demolishing all of the construction work" which had been carried out since 2005.
Dans les Alpes-Maritimes, la justice ordonne la destruction du « château Diter », un palais estimé à 57 millions d'euros https://t.co/L7NrTu5YQT
— Le Parisien (@le_Parisien) March 26, 2019
Diter who was also fined €450,000 will face a further fine of €500 for every day he exceeds the time limit of 18 months specified by the French courts.
Diter was also ordered to pay his neighbours €450,000 in damages, but an earlier imposed six-month suspended jail sentence was waived on appeal.
At Diter's first trial, held back in January 2019, assistant public prosecutor Pierre-Jean Gaury described Diter's transformation of the property as a "pharaonic project, delusional, totally illegal and built illegally."
Gaury added that it was carried out "in violation of urban planning rules, as well as of safety and environmental rules" by an owner whose "only concern is money".
Diter had earlier acknowledged making "mistakes" in carrying out wave after wave of expansion to the farmhouse on the large property he acquired in 1999.
He later sold off part of the estate to a London-based British couple, Stephen and Caroline Butt.
Stephen Butt operates Silchester Partners, an asset management company, and was described by the Sunday Times newspaper as one of the richest fund managers in England.
Over 10 years, he and his wife filed a series of complaints over what they called their neighbour's "building frenzy" and the disturbance caused when the property is let out for large-scale weddings and film shoots.
The property notably featured as Villa Carmella in the first season of Riviera, a TV thriller first broadcast by Sky Atlantic.
Join the conversation in our comments section below. Share your own views and experience and if you have a question or suggestion for our journalists then email us at [email protected].
Please keep comments civil, constructive and on topic – and make sure to read our terms of use before getting involved.
Please log in here to leave a comment.