For members


If France wins the World Cup what does the country really stand to gain?

French fans will be on a high if Les Bleus win the World Cup on Sunday. But apart from the eruption of joy, Emilie King asks, would a victory in Moscow bring about any positive and lasting changes to France?

If France wins the World Cup what does the country really stand to gain?
If France wins the World Cup on Sunday, the entire country will erupt in a victory celebration, Les Bleus will be hailed as national heroes and the French will be swept up in collective ecstasy, just like they were in 1998 when their team last won the golden trophy.
But does the country have more to gain from winning the tournament than a few days of euphoria? 
Studies show that winning the World Cup doesn't only put people in a good mood, it has a positive impact on the economy. After France's 1998 win, French GDP grew by 6% in the quarter that immediately followed, and by 3.4% that year .
More broadly, an ABN Amro study that focused on the economic impact of the World Cup since the 1970s found that, on average, the economy of victorious countries grew by 0.7% compared to the previous year. Nations which lost the final however saw their economy dropping by 0.3%, according to BFMTV.
Winning the World Cup can boost the economy for several reasons. Even if the effects are often short-lived, people tend to spend more, they go out to bars and restaurants, and they splash out on food and sports gear for example. Winning also attracts more business investment.
“It's easier to strike up business relationships and investment with a country that is in the limelight, and football can help to build up the right contacts,” the study explained. 
When consumer confidence gets a boost, this also has a positive impact.
Essentially the theory is that happiness has a strong effect on the consumer. When people are joyous after a World Cup win, they are more likely to go out and buy a new car or an apartment or even a holiday that might have been deemed too expensive before.
What are the other possible effects of the World Cup? In 1998, after France won the tournament on home soil, there was hope the positive momentum would ripple through society. 
Like today's team, back then Les Bleus hailed from diverse ethnic backgrounds. Among them was star Zinedine Zidane, of Algerian descent, Lilian Thuram who was born in Guadeloupe. and Marcel Desailly who was born in Ghana. At a time when the far-right National Front was gaining ground, the win was hailed as a victory for multicultural France.
There was hope that the team's win would help heal some of the country's ills, notably the division over French identity and problems of discrimination towards youths of poor immigrant backgrounds.
But it soon became clear that any expectation of a more united and integrated “Black-Blanc-Beur” (Black-White-Arab) France was futile. The same deep-rooted race problems remained long after the final whistle.
The World Cup win, historian Yvan Gastaut concluded in a 2007 article about immigration and football, had led to nothing more than an “enchanted interlude”.
France's anti-racism campaigner Mouloud Aounit said: “The politicians thought they had solved all the problems through football. In fact, the effect lasted about as long as the fireworks.”
Four years later, far-right National Front leader Jean-Marie Le Pen, who has been convicted of Holocaust denial and racist hate speech made it through to the second round of the presidential elections, leaving many in France stunned and ashamed.
(The victorious so-called Black-Blanc-Beur team of 1998. AFP)
While that ended in a crushing defeat for Le Pen, the National Front, now known as the National Rally, has grown in influence once again in recent years with Marine Le Pen picking up nearly 11 million votes as she lost out to Emmanuel Macron in the 2017 presidential run-off.
But would a win for the Black-Blanc-Beur class of 2018 led by the 18-year-old Kylian Mbappé (photo below) from the Paris suburb of Bondy have more luck in changing attitudes and creating harmony?
Probably not. And there is far less speculation on the potential positive impact of a multi-racial French team this time around.
Speaking about the 1998 World Cup win, former president François Hollande said recently: “We wanted to draw the conclusion that this victory would change French society. It didn’t change it. It’s up to politicians to change it.”

Boys from the banlieues: France football team ignites dreams in gritty estates

One positive measurable impact of the World Cup, however, is on reducing suicide rates in the country. During the 1998 World Cup in France, suicide rates dropped by 10% during the tournament, with the largest drop among men aged 30 to 44. On the day after a France match, the rate fell by 20%.
“The best way to prevent suicide is to build links between people,” French researchers told France Info, which quoted suicide expert Maria Bradshaw. “When the World Cup is on, people feel they have things in common with other people. Even if you feel like an outsider, you end up supporting the same team as others, and wanting the same thing as them,” she said.
One person who will be hoping to get a boost if France wins is Emmanuel Macron, who will be in Moscow on Sunday to support Les Bleus. The French president's popularity ratings are falling – a recent Odoxa poll showed that 75% of the French feel that he is removed from the people.

French president Macron attacked for ‘putting World Cup glory ahead of tackling poverty'

In 1998, the-then president Jacques Chirac's popularity ratings surged after France won, but as Frédéric Dabi, head of Ifop polling agency suggests, this was probably a one-off. 
“1998 was an exception,” he told L'Express. “Jacques Chirac was in a coalition government at the time… and he was therefore exempt from any criticism regarding social or economic issues.”
According to Dabi, France's Euro championship win in 2000 and its defeat in the 2006 World Cup final had no impact on the French presidents at the time, although Macron – who is sometimes dismissively called the 'president of the rich' – may reap some short-term benefits.
“Football can bring him a little closer to the French: it is a sport which can eliminate some social differences,” Dabi said. 
So all in all if the French win on Sunday they should just enjoy the glorious “interlude” as long as it lasts and then hope their politicians can solve the real problems.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.


France plans to keep growing women’s game after World Cup disappointment

France faces the challenge of continuing to develop women's football after the bitter disappointment of elimination from the World Cup by the United States.

France plans to keep growing women's game after World Cup disappointment
France players after the defeat against USA. Photo: AFP

“Back to Earth” was how sports daily L'Equipe put it after the host nation lost 2-1 to the holders in a quarter-final played out before a feverish crowd in Paris.

L'Equipe talked of “the disappointment of a shattered adventure” because coach Corinne Diacre's team had dreamt of emulating the men, World Cup winners in Russia last year and also winners as hosts in 1998.

The team had been desperate to make it to Lyon, where the semi-finals and final will be played and where seven of those who featured for France on Friday play their club football for Europe's top side.

Instead, France find themselves out of a fifth straight major tournament in the quarter-finals. To rub salt into the wounds, Friday's defeat had the knock-on effect of denying them a place at next year's Olympics.

Diacre had been set the objective of reaching the final, which always looked a daunting challenge once the draw raised the likelihood of an early meeting with the USA.

Amid the dejection on Friday, Diacre stated her wish to continue, and on Saturday French Football Federation (FFF) President Noel Le Graet confirmed she would stay.

“She will be in charge until the end of her contract, if not longer,” Le Graet told AFP.

That means until Euro 2021 in England at least, and the aim in France is to keep developing the women's game to give them a chance of one day going all the way.

The FFF hope the number of registered female players will reach 200,000 next year, an increase of almost 10 percent from present figures, but far from the two million registered male players.

They have also promised to invest 15 million euros into a post-World Cup “legacy” fund.

The interest in the women's game is there, as shown by television audiences during the World Cup, with 11.8 million watching the USA game on terrestrial TV.

However, translating that to an increased following in the women's domestic league will be a bigger challenge.

France games have drawn sell-out crowds at the World Cup, but in general attendances in domestic competition are modest at best, even if almost 26,000 saw powerhouses Lyon beat closest rivals Paris Saint-Germain earlier this year.

“We cannot go from so much enthusiasm now to league matches on poor pitches with only 120 fans,” said Le Graet. “We all need to make an effort and we will.”

Matches are televised, but like elsewhere income remains light years from rights deals in the men's game — a new sponsorship contract for the 12-club top flight with chemicals company Arkema is worth one million euros per season for three years.

Average salaries are reportedly around 3,500 euros per month, although stars like Amandine Henry and Wendie Renard are believed to earn almost 10 times that at Lyon, who have won the Champions League in the last four years. Again, those sums are dwarfed by the wages often on offer to the men.

“We need to keep putting money in, keep professionalising, because other countries are doing it and maybe that's why they are ahead of us,” warned Lyon and France forward Eugenie Le Sommer.

“We have a good league but unfortunately not every team is professional.

“There are countries who are ahead of us and we must catch up. Even Spain are putting lots of money in and we need to make sure we are not left behind.”

READ ALSO: France coach laments 'failure' as hosts knocked out of World Cup