France rejects 'intersex' option on official documents
AFP - [email protected]
Published: 5 May, 2017 CET.
Updated: Fri 5 May 2017 08:24 CET
Intersex people born in France cannot hold official documents identifying them as gender neutral, the country's highest appeals court ruled Thursday.
In its ruling against the case of a 65-year-old psychotherapist who uses the pseudonym Gaetan, the court said French law does not allow judges to recognise a neutral sex.
Intersex people have characteristics such as chromosomes or sexual organs that don't clearly fit the typical definitions of male or female.
Gaetan sought to change official documents listing them as male to instead give a neutral gender.
"Gaetan is neither a man nor a woman. They do not feel like a man or woman. They cannot become a man or a woman. And they do not want to become a man or woman," said Gaetan's lawyer Bertrand Perier.
Any judicial recognition of a sex outside the categories of male or female would have "profound repercussions on rules of French law", necessitating a slew of legislative changes, the court said.
The case of Gaetan, who lives in eastern France and is married to a woman, wound through regional courts before landing in the imposing Cour de Cassation on the River Seine in central Paris.
Two years ago, a family affairs judge in Gaetan's birthplace of Tours ruled in the psychotherapist's favour.
The following year, however, an appeals court rejected the ruling, saying it feared the "simple adjustment" of a document risked officially recognising an entirely different gender category.
'I do not belong'
"When I look at myself naked in the mirror, morning or night, I can see I do not belong to a man's world or a woman's world," Gaetan told AFP at the court before the proceedings.
The court Thursday said the plaintiff has, "in the eyes of outsiders, the appearance and social behaviour of someone of the male sex".
According to the United Nations, between 0.05 and 1.7 percent of the global population is intersex -- about the same percent that have red hair.
Sometimes this is apparent at birth, while at other times it becomes noticeable at puberty. Those linked to chromosomes may not be physically evident.
Belgian runway model Hanne Gaby Odiele significantly raised awareness of neutral gender issues earlier this year by publicly revealing that she is intersex.
New York -- America's largest and one of its most liberal cities -- last year issued the first US birth certificate marked "intersex".
Comments
See Also
In its ruling against the case of a 65-year-old psychotherapist who uses the pseudonym Gaetan, the court said French law does not allow judges to recognise a neutral sex.
Intersex people have characteristics such as chromosomes or sexual organs that don't clearly fit the typical definitions of male or female.
Gaetan sought to change official documents listing them as male to instead give a neutral gender.
"Gaetan is neither a man nor a woman. They do not feel like a man or woman. They cannot become a man or a woman. And they do not want to become a man or woman," said Gaetan's lawyer Bertrand Perier.
Any judicial recognition of a sex outside the categories of male or female would have "profound repercussions on rules of French law", necessitating a slew of legislative changes, the court said.
The case of Gaetan, who lives in eastern France and is married to a woman, wound through regional courts before landing in the imposing Cour de Cassation on the River Seine in central Paris.
Two years ago, a family affairs judge in Gaetan's birthplace of Tours ruled in the psychotherapist's favour.
The following year, however, an appeals court rejected the ruling, saying it feared the "simple adjustment" of a document risked officially recognising an entirely different gender category.
'I do not belong'
"When I look at myself naked in the mirror, morning or night, I can see I do not belong to a man's world or a woman's world," Gaetan told AFP at the court before the proceedings.
The court Thursday said the plaintiff has, "in the eyes of outsiders, the appearance and social behaviour of someone of the male sex".
According to the United Nations, between 0.05 and 1.7 percent of the global population is intersex -- about the same percent that have red hair.
Sometimes this is apparent at birth, while at other times it becomes noticeable at puberty. Those linked to chromosomes may not be physically evident.
Belgian runway model Hanne Gaby Odiele significantly raised awareness of neutral gender issues earlier this year by publicly revealing that she is intersex.
New York -- America's largest and one of its most liberal cities -- last year issued the first US birth certificate marked "intersex".
Join the conversation in our comments section below. Share your own views and experience and if you have a question or suggestion for our journalists then email us at [email protected].
Please keep comments civil, constructive and on topic – and make sure to read our terms of use before getting involved.
Please log in here to leave a comment.