Nice security row rumbles on as minister files lawsuit

Despite the efforts of the French president the controversy over the security arrangements on the night of the Nice attack won't go away.

Nice security row rumbles on as minister files lawsuit
Photo: AFP

French President Francois Hollande on Monday sought to defuse a row over allegations his government tried to alter a security report after the Bastille Day massacre in Nice.

A probe into the claim should be allowed to run its course, Hollande said, declaring the truth would be established “(by) the law and no one else.”

“Truth and transparency are essential in a democracy,” he added.

At the centre of the storm is Interior Minister Bernard Cazeneuve, who right-wingers accuse of security failings after France suffered its third major terror attack in 18 months.

Eighty-four people were killed when a truck driven by a 31-year-old Tunisian ploughed through a holiday crowd on the Nice seafront on July 14.

Pressure on Cazeneuve intensified when a local police officer, Sandra Bertin (photo below), accused his ministry of trying to bully her into altering a report on police deployment on the night of the attack.

Prime Minister Manuel Valls waded into the affair on Monday, telling French TV the row was “purely political and aimed at destabilising the government.”

While “obviously we need the truth”, the row should stop, he said, defending Cazeneuve as “a man of integrity, a statesman, and a great interior minister.”

Cazeneuve filed a defamation lawsuit against Bertin, saying her accusations were “likely to give birth in the public mind to the idea that the ministry and the minister have communicated false information” regarding the Nice massacre.

According to the complaint, her words “attack the honour and reputation” of the national police and the minister.

A national police report into the bloodbath had said Mohamed Lahouaiej Bouhlel forced his lorry onto the sidewalk to avoid a police barrier.


But Bertin, who was in charge of the video surveillance system in Nice on the night of the massacre, said on Sunday she was told to describe a police presence that did not match what she had seen on the security camera system.

Bertin said she had been “literally harassed the entire time” that she wrote the report.

“I was asked to change things,” she told a news conference, adding that she was ordered “to put in the specific positions of the national police, which I had not seen on the screen”.

Bertin is a strong supporter of opposition Republicans regional leader Christian Estrosi and has fiercely criticised the Socialist government through social media networks, Le Parisien newspaper reported Monday.

'Destruction of evidence'

On Thursday, the Liberation daily reported that only one local police car was barring entry to Nice's famous Promenade des Anglais when Bouhlel forced his lorry onto the pedestrianised seafront and began his lethal drive.

The furore has been further fuelled by a request from prosecutors that security camera videos of the night of the attack be erased.

Local authorities claimed it amounted to “destruction of evidence” but prosecutors, who already had a copy, said it was to stop “shocking” images of the events — in which 350 people were also hurt — leaking out.

Former Nice mayor Estrosi has also accused the government of lying over the number of police and soldiers protecting the crowds that night.

Cazeneuve's office strongly denied Sunday that he had sent a representative to the local Nice police, “contrary to what Madame Bertin claims”.

Francois Molins, the Paris anti-terrorist prosecutor who is leading the investigation, told AFP he had sent two officers to talk to police in the Nice video unit on July 15 as part of his inquiry.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.


French prosecutors demand magazine’s withdrawal over Nice terror attack images

Relatives of the 86 victims of last year's Nice terror attack have been outraged at a magazine's publication of video surveillance images of the moment a jihadist's truck plowed into the crowd. Prosecutors are demanding the publication be withdrawn.

French prosecutors demand magazine's withdrawal over Nice terror attack images
Photo: AFP

The Paris prosecutor on Thursday demanded the withdrawal of the latest edition of Paris Match which contains surveillance camera images from last year's Bastille Day attack that killed 86 people in Nice.

It asked the court “to order the withdrawal from sale” of the weekly news magazine, which came out Thursday, and “ban publication in all formats, notably digital”, of the issue, which has angered the victims' families.

A judge is to rule on the request at 2pm French time.

The images in question were taken from video surveillance cameras along the Promenade des Anglais, where a Tunisian jihadist plowed his truck into the crowd who had been watching the annual July 14th fireworks show.

The images are believed to show the moments the truck struck the victims, although Paris Match insists no one can be identified.

An investigation is also underway over breach of confidentiality which will try to determine how Paris Match was able to get hold of the images.

Eric Morain, the lawyer for the victims of terror attacks said the images were “an attack on the dignity of both the victims and their families”.

Victims associations have also denounced the publication they say is based solely on a desire to be “sensational” and to create “a morbid and voyeuristic atmosphere” on the anniversary of the attack.

The Mayor of Nice Christian Estrosi described the images as “unbearable and abject”.

But the magazine's editor Olivier Royant justified the publication in a statement.

He said staff “had wanted to pay homage to the victims, by re-visiting them one year later… so that society does not forget them.”

Royant said many of the photos had already been published in the media as well as on TV. He said they images are taken from afar, without identifying anyone and without “attacking their dignity”.

This year, instead of a fireworks display that drew some 30,000 revellers last year to the famous Promenade des Anglais there will be candles, a memory book and a solemn speech by President Emmanuel Macron.