• France's news in English
Opinion - Dual nationals
Why stripping jihadists' French nationality is mad
Photo: AFP

Why stripping jihadists' French nationality is mad

The Local · 5 Jan 2016, 10:28

Published: 05 Jan 2016 10:28 GMT+01:00

Facebook Twitter Google+ reddit

Do you have dual French nationality?If so, how do you feel about being those convicted of terrorist attacks being stripped of their French citizenship?

Posted by The Local France on Monday, 4 January 2016

On the face of it stripping a dual national born in France of his or her French passport after they have been convicted of a terrorist attack on France seems like a no-brainer.

They’ve lost their right to be French when they chose to attack their country and kill their fellow citizens and should be kicked out, so the basic argument goes.

And it’s a message that has won over 90 percent of the French population according to recent opinion polls.

But the measure, which President François Hollande wants written into the constitution and will be debated by MPs in February, has not convinced many in his own party and certainly not human rights organisations.

“We are just falling into the trap that the terrorists have set,” Patrick Baudouin, honorary president of the International Federation of Human Rights (FIDH) told The Local.

“The fear they provoked in the attacks is pushing France to rush through measures that have not been thought through,” Baudouin said.

“Every time there is an attack in France, the French government’s reaction is to push through a law even more repressive than before,” said Baudouin. “They are just reacting to public opinion.

“They want to show they are fighting terrorism but it’s a just a trick.”

'It will do nothing to prevent an attack'

(French people, demonstrate against Isis in Paris. Photo: AFP)

Despite criticism from within his own Socialist party Hollande has remained defiant.

Speaking in his New Year’s address he said while it was "legitimate" to have a debate about the proposal, "when it comes to your protection, France must not be divided".

But the International Federation of Human Rights and dozens of other organisations who signed a petition against the move, argue that it will be anything but effective in “protecting” France.

“Everyone knows this will do nothing to prevent any kind of attack,” Baudouin said.

“Taking someone’s passport off them will hardly affect anything. Have we forgotten that French people who don’t have dual nationality can also commit terrorist attacks?”

Critics also point out that France will find it tough to send citizens stripped of their French passports back to war torn countries like Syria or North African countries, where they may face torture or the death penalty.

“And it’s mad to think that France will send convicted terrorists to another democratic country, like Germany and expect them to take charge of them,” Baudouin said.

Not only that but critics argue it will only make matters worse in France, a country that continues to struggle to integrate immigrants, both first and second generation.

By suggesting the three million dual nationals in France are different from everyone else the reform will only make it harder for that section of the population to feel French, critics argue.

Which again is exactly the aim of the terrorists from Isis, who are desperate to recruit more disaffected French youths to the Jihadi cause.

'Liberté, egalité, fraternité is not the reality'

Baudouin warns that it will “destabilise and divide” the whole country.

“These people will feel stigmatised, left aside from everyone else and considered different," he said. “They will look at France and its principles of liberté, égalité and fraternité and think those are just words because in reality they don't exist.”

Patrick Weil, a political scientist who met Hollande and advised him against the decision told AFP: "The constitution is a text that is written to unify the people and this does the opposite. People know that reinforcing the cohesion of the nation is, in the long term, the only way to defeat terrorism, and this proposal creates an immediate division in the country," he said.

While the reform may send a symbolic message to the would-be jihadists, it also presents a negative image of France and touches a raw nerve.

The Vichy regime, which collaborated with the Nazis in the 1940s, stripped thousands of Jews and foreigners of French citizenship during World War II.

“Our country has always protected the idea of “droit du sol”, so a dual national who is born in France and has French nationality has the right to remain French. But now we are putting this in doubt,” said Baudouin.

“It reminds us of one the worst period of our history,” he said referring to Vichy France.

Story continues below…

Worse still in the eyes of the left, it was an idea first mooted by the far-right, anti-immigrant National Front (FN).

FN leader Marine le Pen happily took credit when the new reforms were outlined last week, saying it was a direct result of her party's record tally in recent polls.

"Removal of nationality: the first effect of the 6.8 million votes for the National Front in regional elections," Le Pen wrote on Twitter.

“An idea put forward by the far right is being pushed through by a left wing government, which claims it is acting in the interests of our country,” Baudouin lamented.

“It’s a real shame”.

The debate about whether France should strip terrorists of the French nationality has divided The Local's readers. Join the debate on our Facebook page.





Facebook Twitter Google+ reddit

Today's headlines
French claims that Jungle camp is empty are rubbished
Photo: AFP

Reports from the scene say scores of migrants are still in the area of the Jungle despite French authorities claiming "mission fulfilled."

Kidnapped Riviera millionaire left tied up in car boot in Nice
Photo: AFP

Head of luxury Cannes hotel has been found alive after being kidnapped in Nice on Monday.

Paris landlords still charging illegally high rents
Photo: Panoramas/Flickr

... and it's tenants in the smaller apartments that get hit the hardest. Could you be paying too much?

France takes baby steps to make life simpler
Photo: AFP

... including extending the ridiculously short time limit for registering a new baby.

IN PICTURES: Calais Jungle camp goes up in flames
All Photos: AFP

Migrants leave behind a scorched camp as they are moved to locations across France.

French expats in UK suffer Brexit abuse
French ambassador to the UK Sylvie Bermann with Foreign Secretary Boris Johnson. Photo: AFP

French nationals no longer feel at home in the UK, ambassador says. But Brits in France have been greeted with sympathy since the referendum.

Six to go on trial in France over topless Kate photos
Photo: AFP

The topless pics sparked fury among the royals.

France sees biggest drop in jobless rate for 20 years
Photo: AFP

Good news at last. But it's unlikely to keep President François Hollande in his job.

Calais migrants given mixed reception in French towns
Photo: AFP

Some in France have shown solidarity with their new guests, while others have made it clear they are not welcome.

Lonely Planet says Bordeaux is world's best city to visit
The fantastic new Bordeaux wine museum. Photo: AFP

After The Local France, the Lonely Planet has followed suit by urging everyone to head to Bordeaux in 2017.

The annoying questions only a half French, half Brit can answer
Sponsored Article
Last chance to vote absentee in the US elections
Forget Brangelina's chateau - here are nine others you've got to see
The must-see French films of the millennium - Part One
How life for expats in France has changed over the years
Why Toulouse is THE place to be in France right now
Video: New homage to Paris shows the 'real side' of city
The 'most dangerous' animals you can find in France
Swap London fogs for Paris frogs: France woos the Brits
Anger after presenter kisses woman's breasts on live TV
Is France finally set for a cold winter this year?
IN PICS: The story of the 'ghost Metro stations' of Paris
How to make France's 'most-loved' dish: Magret de Canard
Welcome to the flipside: 'I'm not living the dream in France'
Do the French really still eat frogs' legs?
French 'delicacies' foreigners really find hard to stomach
French are the 'world's most pessimistic' about the future
Why the French should not be gloomy about the future
This is the most useful French lesson you will ever have. How to get angry
Why is there a giant clitoris in a field in southern France?
French pastry wars: Pain au chocolat versus chocolatine
Countdown: The ten dishes the French love the most
Expats or immigrants in France: Is there a difference?
How the French reinvented dozens of English words
jobs available