US Spying: Fake French shock fools no one

While the French political world reacted with anger and shock – at least publicly – to the revelations that the US spied on the country's presidents and demanded firm action, the reality is, while they may have been a little angry, no one was truthfully shocked.

US Spying: Fake French shock fools no one
"Look there's nothing we can do" - Hollande meets with his defence council on Wednesday. Photo: AFP

Destroy part of the American embassy in Paris; expel US diplomats; grant asylum to Edward Snowden and Julian Assange; end negotiations on the transatlantic free trade treaty.

These were just some of the suggestions made by outraged French politicians on Wednesday who were reacting to the revelations that the US spied on presidents Jacques Chirac, Nicolas Sarkozy and most recently François Hollande.

So it appears, publicly at least, that almost 130 years to the day since France gave the US a gift in the form of the Statue of Liberty, relations between the two nations have dramatically soured.

The US ambassador was summoned, Hollande called an urgent defence council, the French government publicly declared the spying was “unacceptable”, and the president ordered Barack Obama on the phone.

With the French PM Manuel Valls also saying publicly that the US “must work to repair relations”, things sound pretty bad.

France may have expressed its outrage over the presidential snooping but much of the shock is feigned, experts say.

“It's blindingly obvious,” said Alain Chouet, former intelligence chief at France's DGSE spy agency. “Everyone knows the NSA (US National Security Agency) has developed a system of acquiring data from the entire world since 2003.”

The reality is, experts say, dealings between the two countries that face each other across the Atlantic and are currently allies in the war against Isis won’t change because of a little bit of presidential snooping.


When François Hollande spoke on the phone to Barack Obama on Wednesday they are as likely to have spent more time discussing wine and cheese than spying.

“President Obama will no doubt say something to Hollande like ‘we have suddenly discovered this, it’s over now, we have so much in common and when are you coming over to Washington next my dear François?’” Francois-Bernard Huyghe, a senior adviser at France’s Institute of International and Strategic Relations (IRIS) told The Local.

“These spying revelations come as no surprise to anyone who isn’t naïve,” said Huyghe.

“We’ve known about the Americans spying since the 1990s. What can France do? Frankly nothing. It is so heavily involved with the US and the government is pro-American.

“We are not going to see the TTIP negotiations suspended or Snowden granted Asylum, or any economic sanctions,” he said.

Wednesday’s revelations that the NSA wiretapped three French presidents sound like a recipe for a major diplomatic scandal, but ever since whistleblower Edward Snowden blew the lid on the extent of US spying, the new claims hardly felt surprising.

It had already been revealed that the Americans snooped on the mobile phone of German Chancellor Angela Merkel, and in October 2013 France was made aware that the US spied on the mobile phones of thousands of ordinary French people.

Back then Le Monde newspaper claimed the US spy agency NSA recorded 70 million phone calls made in France in one month.

After those revelations Hollande also picked up the phone to Obama and apparently told him that all this listening in was “unacceptable” – the same word used over and again by French politicians on Wednesday.

The pair vowed to work together and life quickly returned to normal, which is exactly what we can expect to happen this time around, argues Nicolas Dungan, a senior fellow at the Atlantic Council.

“It’s a storm in a tea cup. Nothing will happen and it will be allowed to blow over,” he told The Local.

“Hollande has no choice but to say publicly ‘the president of the United States has no business spying on me', but he knows what is happening.

“When it comes to spying, the French know exactly what the US can do and the US knows what the French can do and they probably both expect the other side do everything they can,” said Dungan.

But perhaps the most appropriate words spoken on Wednesday came in statement from France's Socialist party, who accused the US of “astounding state paranoia”.

“Just because we knew or suspected that these massive, systematic and uncontrolled wiretaps were in place, it doesn't mean they are tolerable.”


Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.


Assange urges France to take action against US

WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange told French television Wednesday that the time had come for legal action over US snooping after leaked documents revealing Washington had spied on three French presidents sparked fresh outrage.

Assange urges France to take action against US
Wikileaks founder Julian Assange has urged France to take legal action against the US. Photo: AFP

Speaking on TF1, the anti-secrecy campaigner urged France to go further than Germany: by launching a “parliamentary inquiry” into the foreign surveillance activities and refering “the matter to the prosecutor-general for prosecution”.

German prosecutors had carried out a probe into alleged tapping on Chancellor Angela Merkel's phone, but later dropped the investigation due to a lack of hard evidence.

Assange also said other important revelations were coming.

“I think from a policy perspective what is to come is much more significant than what we have published so far,” he said.

“But now the question really for (President Francois) Hollande and the French leadership is what are the opportunities in their response to address this situation.”

France expressed anger earlier Wednesday after leaked documents labelled “top secret” appeared to reveal US spying on Hollande and his two predecessors, Nicolas Sarkozy and Jacques Chirac, between 2006 and 2012. The disclosures were published by WikiLeaks along with French newspaper Liberation and the Mediapart website.

France's foreign minister summoned the US ambassador for a formal explanation in response, while Hollande spoke by phone by with US President Barack Obama, who gave fresh assurances that spying on European leaders had ended.

But Assange accused the US of playing “word games”, as it did after revelations of US eavedropping on Merkel.

“What does it matter if they say that they're not going to spy on Hollande personally if they're spying on everyone he talks to?” Assange asked.

“Every single one of these intercepted phone calls that we have published is Hollande talking to someone else, Sarkozy talking to someone else, one of the members of the French government. What does it matter if they say that they're not going to spy on Hollande personally if they're spying on everyone he talks to?”