New setback for French 'anti-Semitic' comic

AFP - [email protected] • 11 Jan, 2014 Updated Sat 11 Jan 2014 10:25 CEST
image alt text

France's top legal advisory body upheld a ban on controversial comic Dieudonne's show for the second night running Friday, and officials moved to stop upcoming performances in Paris.


The Conseil d'Etat confirmed a decision banning Dieudonne M'Bala M'Bala's show in the city of Tours on the grounds that his diatribes against Jews posed a threat to public order.

The comic had suffered a first setback when the tribunal overturned a decision giving the show the go-ahead in Nantes on Thursday, the first date of a national tour.

"We'll be there again tomorrow," said Sanjay Mirabeau, one of Dieudonne's lawyers, pledging to try to strike down a ban on Saturday's show in Orleans.

The legal tussling pits France's commitment to freedom of expression against restrictions on hate speech.

The French government has branded Dieudonne -- who has been repeatedly convicted in the past under anti-racism legislation -- a "peddler of hate" for his sketches, widely viewed as anti-Semitic.

The interior ministry has urged local authorities in towns to host his nationwide run of stand-up shows to ban them on public order grounds.

The comic has challenged each ban individually in local courts. And, so far, lost.

Paris police announced Friday that it was slapping bans on several shows scheduled over the coming days in the capital, setting the stage for more days of legal battles.

Dieudonne's supporters, and even some who reject his brand of humour but defend his right to express himself, have displayed concern over what they say is a troubling breach of freedom of speech.

Several legal experts told AFP that the court decisions on Dieudonne will serve as precedents in other cases -- and warned that the European Court of Human Rights could still scuttle France's stance.

But French government lawyers argue the fundamentally racist nature of the comedian's act means it cannot be afforded protection under France's constitutional provisions on freedom of speech.

Preview performances of his "The Wall" tour in Paris included a sketch in which the comedian mimed urinating against a wall. He then reveals that it was the Wailing Wall in Jerusalem.

He also directs volleys of abuse at prominent French Jewish performers, rounding off one rant about radio presenter Patrick Cohen with the observation: "Gas chambers ... a shame."

And he has been slammed for his trademark "quenelle" stiff-arm gesture, which has been described as a disguised Nazi salute.

The gesture, which Dieudonne insists is purely an "up yours" to the French establishment, has taken on a life of its own.

Some people have been caught on camera doing the quenelle at Auschwitz or outside synagogues in France.

Dieudonne, now 47, started his career as part of a double act with a Jewish childhood friend, Elie Semoun.

But he veered towards anti-Semitism and the change burst into the open in 2003, when he concluded a televised sketch for which he had dressed up as an extremist Jew with a Nazi salute.



AFP 2014/01/11 10:25

Please keep comments civil, constructive and on topic – and make sure to read our terms of use before getting involved.

Please log in to leave a comment.

See Also