French students’ union guilty of drinking death

A French court on Tuesday found a students' union guilty of manslaughter for organizing a party at which a student drank himself to death, and which highlighted the heavy binge-drinking culture at French universities.

French students' union guilty of drinking death
A French court on Tuesday found a students' union guilty of manslaughter for organizing a party which led a student to drink himself to death. Archive photo: Winnie Liu

A court in Nanterre, near Paris, on Tuesday found a students' association guilty of manslaughter for allowing hard alcohol to be served at a student party in 2005, during which a 19-year-old man drank 15 shots in half an hour, before dying of an alcohol-induced coma.

The then-president of the students' union, however, was acquitted of manslaughter.

On the night of September 22nd, 2005, newly-enrolled Alexander Thomas attended a special Roma-themed “student night” on the Châtenay-Malbry campus of the prestigious Ecole Centrale engineering school, near the French capital.

There, he drank no fewer than 15 shots of a so-called ‘Roma cocktail’ – vodka, Cointreau and lemon juice – in less than half an hour, according to French daily Le Monde.

The 19-year-old was carried back to his room by friends, who checked in on him the next day, only to find he had died during the night.

An autopsy found he had a staggering four grammes of alcohol in his system at the time of his death, which was caused by an alcohol-induced coma, a pathologist concluded.

Eight years on, the main defendant in the case stood accused of criminal negligence in his capacity as president of the university’s Residents’ Association, which organized the fateful “student night.”

During a hearing at the court in Nanterre, near Paris, the prosecutor accused the suspect of “a deliberate failure in [his] obligation to prudence and safety.”

The students’ association itself, convicted of manslaughter on Tuesday afternoon, only had a Level 2 alcohol license at the time, meaning it was allowed to serve beer, wine and cider, but not hard spirits.

The former president of the union acknowledged this fact, but claimed that the practice of serving and drinking liquor was tolerated on rare occasions.

Prosecutors had called for a six-month suspended prison sentence against the defendant, who is now a neuroscience researcher based in the United States.

In the end, the association was on Tuesday handed a symbolic €7,500 fine.

The tragedy brought to light what had become a rampant culture of heavy drinking on the campuses of French universities, in particular the most elite among them – the “Grandes Ecoles.”

Just weeks after the death of Thomas, French magazine L’Express published a scathing opinion column, condemning the “orgies of alcohol” that had permeated French third-level education.

“The exceptional nature of this drama [the death of Thomas] shouldn’t hide a daily reality that is as normalized as it is disturbing,” wrote Henri Haget.

“Based on the image of the American college campus, student parties – especially in the grandes écoles – are more and more often just an excuse for orgies of alcohol,” said Haget.

Ultimately, the episode helped contribute to the 2009 Bachelot Law on public health, which – among other measures – banned free "open bar" nights at pubs and clubs, targeted at university students.

While the events at the centre of Tuesday's ruling took place in 2005, binge drinking among France's youth more generally, doesn't seem to have abated since then.

Back in March, The Local reported a study which found that alcohol abuse had become the number one cause of hospitalisation in the country, with short emergency room stays for injuries related to drunken trips and falls skyrocketing by 80 percent in just three years.

“Getting plastered on a night out has become a real badge of honour for many of our young people, especially young women, which is particularly disturbing,” gastroenterologist Dr. Damien Labarrière said at the time.

Those revelations came just two weeks after a report which found that, among the general population, 134 people died in France every day, from alcohol-related illnesses and incidents.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.


France to make period products free for students

The French government said on Tuesday it would make period products free for students, joining a global drive to end "period poverty" - the inability to pay for menstrual protection.

France to make period products free for students
Last year, Scotland became the first country in the world to offer free universal access to period products. Photo: Andy Buchanan / AFP

Higher Education Minister Frederique Vidal said that machines containing free tampons, sanitary towels and other period products would be installed in student residences and university health services in the coming weeks.

She added that the government aimed to make period protection “completely free of charge” for all by the start of the next academic year in September.

In November, Scotland became the first country in the world to make period products free for all, blazing a trail that inspired feminists and anti-poverty campaigners around the world to also take up the issue of period poverty.

In England, free period products are available in all primary and secondary schools – a move New Zealand said last week it too would implement.

In December, President Emmanuel Macron had promised to also address the issue of period poverty.

Commenting on the plight of homeless women, he noted that “the fact of having your period in the street and to not be able to buy something to protect yourself and preserve your dignity” added to the humiliation they suffered.

The move to make sanitary protection free for students comes amid a growing focus on youth poverty following shock images of food banks being swamped by hard-up students due to the Covid-19 pandemic.

Many students say they are struggling to make ends meet after losing part-time jobs in cafes and restaurants which have been closed for months due to the health crisis.