French Church changes 'blasphemous' prayer
After nearly half a century of theological debate, French bishops have decided to change a potentially "blasphemous" version of the Lord's Prayer, to be included in a forthcoming French-language bible.
In a ruling long advocated by traditionalists and with implications for other-language versions of the prayer, the bishops have approved a new edition of the French-language bible which will include a revised wording of one of the prayer's best-known lines, "Lead us not into temptation."
The existing French version of that line reads, "Et ne nous soumets pas ą la tentation", which translates as "Do not submit us to temptation."
This has long been controversial because of the possibility of interpreting it in a way that suggests God has the power to make people succumb to the temptation of sin.
This contradicts most orthodox Christian theology, which holds that He is infinitely and unchangeably good.
In the revised formulation, to be included in new bibles published on November 22nd, the line will read "Et ne nous laisse pas entrer en tentation" or "Let us not enter into temptation."
The change was authorized by the Vatican in July along with the rest of a new translation of the bible into French from the original texts, which were written in a number of different languages.
The task, involving 70 linguistic and theological experts, has taken 17 years to complete.
The current version of the Lord's Prayer has been used in France since 1966.
Ironically, the disputed wording was the result of an attempt to agree on a common version for both Catholic and Protestant churches.
France's small Protestant congregations however never adopted the phrase, opting instead for "Let us not enter into temptation."
Don't miss a story about France - Join us on Facebook and Twitter
Comments
See Also
In a ruling long advocated by traditionalists and with implications for other-language versions of the prayer, the bishops have approved a new edition of the French-language bible which will include a revised wording of one of the prayer's best-known lines, "Lead us not into temptation."
The existing French version of that line reads, "Et ne nous soumets pas ą la tentation", which translates as "Do not submit us to temptation."
This has long been controversial because of the possibility of interpreting it in a way that suggests God has the power to make people succumb to the temptation of sin.
This contradicts most orthodox Christian theology, which holds that He is infinitely and unchangeably good.
In the revised formulation, to be included in new bibles published on November 22nd, the line will read "Et ne nous laisse pas entrer en tentation" or "Let us not enter into temptation."
The change was authorized by the Vatican in July along with the rest of a new translation of the bible into French from the original texts, which were written in a number of different languages.
The task, involving 70 linguistic and theological experts, has taken 17 years to complete.
The current version of the Lord's Prayer has been used in France since 1966.
Ironically, the disputed wording was the result of an attempt to agree on a common version for both Catholic and Protestant churches.
France's small Protestant congregations however never adopted the phrase, opting instead for "Let us not enter into temptation."
Don't miss a story about France - Join us on Facebook and Twitter
Join the conversation in our comments section below. Share your own views and experience and if you have a question or suggestion for our journalists then email us at [email protected].
Please keep comments civil, constructive and on topic – and make sure to read our terms of use before getting involved.
Please log in here to leave a comment.