Row after minister says nuclear is the future

French Greens reacted angrily on Monday after a government minister described nuclear power as the "energy of the future," casting doubt on a commitment to slash the country's number of reactors.

The Greens, minority partners in France's Socialist-led administration, lashed out at Industrial Recovery Minister Arnaud Montebourg for comments in which he lauded France's nuclear industry as a "tremendous asset."

"We need energy that is not too expensive," Montebourg said.

France is the world's most nuclear-dependent country, operates 58 reactors and has been a leading international proponent of atomic energy.   

But in a deal with the Greens before this year's parliamentary and presidential elections, the Socialists promised to reduce reliance on nuclear energy from more than 75 percent to 50 percent by shutting 24 reactors by 2025.

The Greens, who have 17 seats in the 577-member National Assembly and two ministers in the government, have pushed for alternative sources like wind and solar power to replace nuclear energy.

"This is a provocation…. It is very worrying to see these statements from someone who is not isolated, who is an important member of the government," said former Green presidential candidate Noel Mamere.

"If there is no explanation or questioning of Mr. Montebourg's statements, we environmentalists will be entitled to question the validity of the agreements that saw us enter this majority," he said.

The vice president of the Greens' parliamentary group, Denis Baupin, said Montebourg's remarks were "completely at odds with reality", while a Green Party spokesman said they were "isolated statements" that did not represent government policy.

Montebourg said Monday he had been "talking sense", and following Hollande's election promises. He noted that the nuclear industry employed more than half a million people directly or indisrectly in France.

Interior Minister Manuel Valls backed his colleague, saying nuclear energy was "undeniably" a part of France's energy future.

"We need nuclear (energy), even if we are reducing its share in the decade to come," Valls said.

Green Party Housing Minister Cécile Duflot downplayed the remarks, saying President François Hollande's government would stick by its promises.

"This agreement will be met. The president's commitments apply to everyone," Duflot said.

"I am among those who believe that what commits a government are its actions," she said.

Socialist Party spokesman David Assouline also said the remarks were an expression of Montebourg's "personal feelings" and did not reflect government policy.

Environmental group Greenpeace denounced the "cacophony" of different opinions within the government on nuclear policy.

"This situation is, unfortunately, typical of the methods Hollande began using during the presidential campaign: considering everyone's opinion without making any clear or strategic choice," Karine Gavand, head of political affairs at Greenpeace, said in a statement.

France's reliance on nuclear power has been increasingly called into question since the Fukushima disaster in Japan, which prompted Germany to announce plans to shut all of its reactors by the end of 2022.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.


France increases to €9,000 grants for property owners

A French scheme to provide financial aid to property owners seeking to replace oil and gas boilers with eco-friendly alternatives has been extended, with grants of up to €9,000 now available.

France increases to €9,000 grants for property owners

The French government will increase the amount of money available to replace gas and oil-powered boilers through the MaPrimeRenov’ scheme, part of a package of measures announced by Prime Minister Jean Castex on Wednesday

Environment Minister Barbara Pompili said that from April 15th, some households would be able to benefit from an extra €1,000 to “accelerate the replacement of fossil fuel-powered boilers with renewable heating solutions”, such as heat pumps and biomass heaters. 

It will no longer be possible to use state funding to replace a gas boiler with another, more efficient gas boiler. 

This brings the total state aid available for replacing boilers up to €9,000. 

Who can benefit? 

The funding for boiler replacement is available through the MaPrimeRenov’ scheme – which is available to anyone who owns property in France. 

Applicants for funding do however need a French numéro fiscal (tax number) and a copy of their latest tax declaration, which means those who do not file the annual tax declaration in France are effectively excluded. 

You can only apply for funding if your property is more than two years old. 

The amount of money you could receive depends on a range of criteria including: household income; the number of people living in the household; and the location of the property. 

You can read more about the MaPrimeRenov’ scheme HERE

Why is the government doing this? 

The move essentially allows France to faire d’une pierre deux coups – hit two birds with one stone.

One one hand, it will allow the country to cut down on greenhouse gas emissions in the face of the global climate crisis. 

On the other, it allows France to reduce its dependency on Russian gas – which has become a government priority ever since the invasion of Ukraine.

French Prime Minister Jean Castex said the government would target and end to dependency on Russian energy by 2027. The construction of new nuclear plants announced in February will also assist in reaching this objective.

You can read more about the government’s measures to insulate the French economy from the war in Ukraine HERE