Turkey's ambassador was to leave Paris on Friday in a row with France over a law making it a criminal offence to deny that a massacre of Armenians by Ottoman troops in 1915 amounted to genocide.

"/> Turkey's ambassador was to leave Paris on Friday in a row with France over a law making it a criminal offence to deny that a massacre of Armenians by Ottoman troops in 1915 amounted to genocide.

" />


Turkish envoy to leave Paris after vote

Turkey's ambassador was to leave Paris on Friday in a row with France over a law making it a criminal offence to deny that a massacre of Armenians by Ottoman troops in 1915 amounted to genocide.

Ankara froze military and diplomatic ties with Paris on Thursday after the French parliament approved the draft law, while the Turkish embassy in Paris said its ambassador had been recalled and would leave Friday.


“This is politics based on racism, discrimination and xenophobia,” Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan said on Thursday, warning of “irreparable damage” to relations and suspending political visits between the two NATO allies.

“From now on we are revising our relations with France,” he added. “There was no genocide committed in our history. We do not accept this.”

Under the draft law, people can be jailed for a year and fined €45,000 ($59,000) for denying that the killings of hundreds of thousands of Armenians by Ottoman Turk forces during World War I amounted to genocide.

In retaliation, Turkey’s premier said the country would rule on a case-by-case basis on any French request to use Turkish airspace or military bases and would turn away French military vessels from Turkish ports.

Turkey would also boycott an economic committee meeting in Paris in January, Erdogan said — a move that will worry business leaders in both countries fearful for the fate of €12 billion ($16 billion) in annual trade.

In Paris, Foreign Minister Alain Juppé termed Turkey’s decision regrettable, and urged the country not to “overreact”.

“Turkey is an ally of France and a strategic partner,” Juppe said, citing work done by the states in NATO and the G20 to address the crisis in Syria, bring peace to Afghanistan and develop security in the Mediterranean.

“What I wish is that our Turkish friends will not overreact to this decision by the French National Assembly (parliament).”

Supporters say the draft law, which will now be debated by the Senate and parliamentary committees and may be enacted early next year, is an overdue measure to ensure one of the 20th century’s worst massacres is not forgotten.

But Turkey argues that Armenia’s estimate of 1.5 million dead is exaggerated. It puts the death toll at about 500,000 and denies the genocide label — ascribing the deaths to fighting and starvation during World War I and accusing the Armenians of siding with Russian invaders.

The United States urged France and Turkey — both NATO members – to de-escalate the row.

“We obviously want to see good relations between France and Turkey, we hope they can resolve differences between them, they’re both stalwart NATO allies and partners,” a US senior diplomat said on condition of anonymity.

Erdogan accused France’s President Nicolas Sarkozy of pandering to domestic voters, and warned of an escalating scale of Turkish sanctions against France.

“History and people will never forgive those exploiting historical facts to achieve political ends,” he said.

Sarkozy’s government insists the law was a parliamentary idea, but it was drafted by members of his UMP party and was passed in the first of a series of votes by a small number of lawmakers in a sparsely attended house.

The move was also criticized at home, with socialist presidential candidate Francois Hollande denouncing it as “an electoral operation” and former justice minister Robert Badinter deeming it “unconstitutional”.

Angry crowds in Ankara chanted: “We have not committed genocide, we defended the homeland. Wait for us France, we will come.”

Armenia’s Foreign Minister Edward Nalbandian, however, expressed his gratitude to France, which he said had “once again proved its commitment to universal human values”.

France is home to around 500,000 citizens of Armenian descent and they are seen as a key source of support for Sarkozy and the UMP ahead of presidential and legislative elections in April and June next year.

Franco-Turkish relations are often tense — Sarkozy is a firm opponent of allowing Turkey to join the European Union — but 1,000 French firms work there.

Much of Europe, including France, is facing recession amid a sovereign debt crisis, but Turkey enjoys growth rates in excess of eight percent and, with 78 million people, it is a huge potential market.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.


Erdogan calls French separatism bill ‘guillotine’ of democracy

Turkey's President Recep Tayyip Erdogan on Wednesday denounced a planned French law designed to counter "Islamist separatism" as a "guillotine" of democracy.

Erdogan calls French separatism bill 'guillotine' of democracy
Erdogan has already denounced the proposed measures as "anti-Muslim". Photo: Adem ALTAN/AFP

The draft legislation has been criticised both inside France and abroad for stigmatising Muslims and giving the state new powers to limit speech and religious groups.

“The adoption of this law, which is openly in contradiction of human rights, freedom of religion and European values, will be a guillotine blow inflicted on French democracy,” said Erdogan in a speech in Ankara.

The current version of the planned law would only serve the cause of extremism, putting NGOs under pressure and “forcing young people to choose between their beliefs and their education”, he added.

READ ALSO: What’s in France’s new law to crack down on Islamist extremism?

“We call on the French authorities, and first of all President (Emmanuel) Macron, to act sensibly,” he continued. “We expect a rapid withdrawal of this bill.”

Erdogan also said he was ready to work with France on security issues and integration, but relations between the two leaders have been strained for some time.

France’s government is in the process of passing new legislation to crack down on what it has termed “Islamist separatism”, which would give the state more power to vet and disband religious groups judged to be threats to the nation.

Erdogan has already denounced the proposed measures as “anti-Muslim”.

READ ALSO: Has Macron succeeded in creating an ‘Islam for France’?

Last October, Erdogan questioned Macron’s “mental health”, accusing him of waging a “campaign of hatred” against Islam, after the French president defended the right of cartoonists to caricature the prophet Mohammed.

The two countries are also at odds on a number of other issues, including Libya, Syria and the eastern Mediterranean.