• France's news in English

'Golden' budget rule too complicated: economists

AFP · 29 Aug 2011, 06:29

Published: 29 Aug 2011 16:29 GMT+02:00
Updated: 29 Aug 2011 06:29 GMT+02:00

Facebook Twitter Google+ reddit

French President Nicolas Sarkozy wants to push through a balanced budget amendment, dubbed the "golden rule", to reassure rattled markets, but economists complain the measure is too complicated.

Work on the golden rule has been underway for months, but after markets took a beating a couple weeks ago on false rumours France's credit rating was to be downgraded over the eurozone debt drama, it has gained a new urgency.  

The effort was applauded by German Chancellor Angela Merkel at a recent summit with Sarkozy, with balanced budget rules becoming a political leitmotif for European leaders.  

In France however, the opposition Socialists, whose votes are needed to amend France's constitution, have so far refused to go along with the measure, all but eliminating its chances of becoming law.  

Economists, even ones who support a balanced budget amendment in principle, say the Sarkozy version is essentially toothless.  

"I think it is very important to have a 'golden rule' and in the current situation it's indispensable and urgent," Charles Wyplosz, professor at the Graduate Institute of International and Development Studies in Geneva, said.  

"But not this version which is complicated, far-fetched, badly done, imprecise and easily circumvented," he said.  

The "golden rule" announced in March by the Sarkozy government isn't actually a balanced budget amendment per se, but a renewable law that would establish deficit targets for the subsequent three years.  

If the targets were missed, France's constitutional council could then strike down spending laws such as the annual budget and/or social security financing.  

Wyplosz said the proposal was "a pile of laws" that vaguely promises a balanced budget, "but doesn't explain what it means, how we get there, nor when."  

France already has a commitment to budget discipline with the Maastricht treaty, said Henri Sterdyniak from the French Economic Observatory who believed that measures like the "golden rule" are counterproductive in crisis times.  

In 1992, the Maastricht treaty laid down the foundations for the eurozone, the now 17-member single currency union, and required countries adopting the euro to keep public deficits at 3.0 percent of gross domestic product and public debt at 60 percent of GDP.  

Sterdyniak pleaded for a "real" golden rule, an idea by French economist Paul Leroy-Beaulieu in the 19th century that a state should only borrow what it invests towards the future, like infrastructure and research.  

Local governments in France already have such a restriction.  

"When economic activity is bad, we are forced to run deficits," Sterdyniak said, noting that Sarkozy defended that notion as he navigated the 2008 financial crisis.  

The economist argued that countries like France had to only keep deficits under the eurozone ceiling of three percent of annual output.  

"That would ensure that our debt stays pretty much stable," Sterdyniak said.  

Jacques Delpla, who as a member of the French government's Council of Economic Analysis helped come up with the current "golden rule" proposal, said that the amendment would only work if it was credible.  

Story continues below…

"A budgetary rule allows you to avoid barbaric deficit reductions when you move out a crisis," Delpla said.  

"When interest rates are low, we are tempted to let the debt accumulate. Then we explode when rates increase again."  

Delpla said that France should learn from the Germans and Swiss who have constitutional amendments that limit deficits to 0.35 percent of GDP and can be modified according to circumstances.  

France last had a balanced budget in 1973 and all pledges to save tax receipts in the good years for difficult times ahead have been sabotaged by politics, Wyplosz said.  

"It's what we've never been able to do in France. That is, whether good year or bad, we've always run deficits," Wyplosz said.  

"My worry is that by passing this law as is, in a few years it won't have worked and the principle itself will be discredited because the version adopted was the wrong one," he said.

Facebook Twitter Google+ reddit

Today's headlines
How life for expats in France has changed over the years
A market in Eymet, southwestern France. Photo: AFP

Foreigners in France explain how life has changed over the years.

London calling for Calais youths, but only a chosen few
Photo: AFP

Dozens of Calais minors are still hanging their hopes on help from the UK, but not all will be so lucky.

17 different ways to talk about sex in French
Photo: Helga Weber/Flickr

Fancy a quick run with the one-legged man?

Yikes! This is what a rat-infested French jail looks like
Photo: YouTube/France Bleu TV.

This video is not for sufferers of ratophobia (or musophobia as the condition is officially called).

France to allow Baby Jesus in Town Halls this Christmas
Photo: AFP

Mary, Joseph, and baby Jesus are safe to go on display again this year, it seems.

National Front posts locations of migrants in French town
The National Front courts controversy. Photo: AFP

"Local tax payers have a right to know," says local far-right party chief.

Paris thieves use tear gas to steal €500,000 of watches
Photo: AFP

The thieves pretended to be couriers then threatened staff with tear gas to get the watches.

Bataclan survivor recounts attack in chilling drawings
Photo: BFMTV screengrab

One survivor has recounted the horrific night through illustrations.

Anger among French police grows as Hollande vows talks
French police demonstrate on the Champs Elysées. Photo: AFP

A fourth night of protests shows government efforts to ease anger among French police have been fruitless.

UK border must move back, says 'next French president'
Photo: AFP

If favourite Alain Juppé is elected, Britain and France are in for some difficult negotiations.

Sponsored Article
How to vote absentee from abroad in the US elections
Why Toulouse is THE place to be in France right now
Sponsored Article
Last chance to vote absentee in the US elections
Video: New homage to Paris shows the 'real side' of city
The 'most dangerous' animals you can find in France
Sponsored Article
How to vote absentee from abroad in the US elections
Swap London fogs for Paris frogs: France woos the Brits
Anger after presenter kisses woman's breasts on live TV
Is France finally set for a cold winter this year?
IN PICS: The story of the 'ghost Metro stations' of Paris
How to make France's 'most-loved' dish: Magret de Canard
Welcome to the flipside: 'I'm not living the dream in France'
Do the French really still eat frogs' legs?
French 'delicacies' foreigners really find hard to stomach
French are the 'world's most pessimistic' about the future
Why the French should not be gloomy about the future
This is the most useful French lesson you will ever have. How to get angry
Why is there a giant clitoris in a field in southern France?
French pastry wars: Pain au chocolat versus chocolatine
Countdown: The ten dishes the French love the most
Expats or immigrants in France: Is there a difference?
How the French reinvented dozens of English words
The ups and downs of being both French and English
How Brexit vote has changed life for expats in France
Twelve French insults we'd love to have in English
What's on in France: Ten of the best events in October
jobs available