• France's news in English
 
app_header_v3

Blood on cloth didn't belong to King Louis XVI

The Local/AFP · 24 Apr 2014, 16:33

Published: 24 Apr 2014 16:33 GMT+02:00

Two centuries after the French people beheaded King Louis XVI and dipped their handkerchiefs in his blood, DNA analysis has thrown new doubt on the authenticity of one such rag kept as a morbid souvenir.

The contents of an ornately-decorated gourd alleged to hold traces of the king's dried blood has long been the subject of scientific disagreement, with tests throwing up contradictory results.

On Thursday, a team from Europe and the United States said they had sequenced the full genome of the DNA in the squash, and found it was unlikely to be from someone tall or blue-eyed -- both features ascribed to the 18th century monarch.

"The results of these analyses do not support the royal identity of the sequenced genome," the authors concluded in a study in the journal Nature Scientific Reports.

Researchers have been trying for years to verify a claim imprinted on the calabash that: "On January 21, Maximilien Bourdaloue dipped his handkerchief in the blood of Louis XVI after his decapitation" in Paris in 1793.

He is then said to have placed the fabric in the dried, hollow gourd and had it embellished with portraits of revolutionary heroes.

In 2010, a study said DNA analysis of blood traces found inside the ornate vegetable revealed a match for someone of Louis' description, including his blue eyes.

One of the authors of that paper, Carles Lalueza-Fox of the Institute of Evolutionary Biology in Barcelona, also participated in the latest study, which contradicts the blue-eyed finding.

He told AFP the latest DNA analysis was much more complete: "we have now the whole genome of the person (in) the gourd."

(Screengrab/NBC News)

It's in the eyes

Lalueza-Fox said about 76 percent of the DNA in the calabash belonged to a single person whose genetic signature, from northern Italy, was not "compatible" with Louis' known, more central-European ancestry.

The individual likely had brown eyes and was of average height -- contrary to the king's description as the tallest person in the royal court.

In 2012, Lalueza-Fox had co-authored yet another paper concluding the blood in the gourd was indeed from Louis -- based on DNA shared with a mummified head said to belong to the king's predecessor, Henri IV.

By drawing a paternal genetic link between the remains of two men separated by over seven generations, Lalueza-Fox and French expert Philippe Charlier said at the time they had authenticated both royal relics -- a finding now seemingly thrown into doubt.

Royal connection? 

Several other studies have found evidence for the head belonging to Henri-- physical features matching portraits of the king, as well as data from radiocarbon dating, 3D scanning and X-rays.

But research led by Belgian geneticist Jean-Jacques Cassiman last year found no genetic link between the DNA of living relatives of the Bourbon kings and the remains in the gourd or the mummified head.

Henri was assassinated by a fanatic Catholic in 1610, and his head is believed to have been saved from the ransacking of the royal chapel at Saint-Denis, north of Paris, during the French Revolution.

Story continues below…

Charlier told AFP the link he and Lalueza-Fox had found between the two specimens "may have been coincidental".

"It does not place into doubt the authenticity of the head of Henri IV," he insisted.

Lalueza-Fox said the remaining 24 percent of DNA found in the gourd belonged to at least three other people who had touched the handkerchief -- but none had any Bourbon DNA markers either.

"It could still be possible, although implausible, that the gourd's blood could be that of the French king," the study concluded.

Hank Greely, a genetics ethics expert at Stanford University, said he doubted this was the end of the blood saga.

"Fundamentally, though, this is how science works. People do studies, they agree or disagree... they get followed up with more and better to see why and how there were differences -- and who, if anyone, was right."

For more news from France, join us on Facebook and Twitter.

The Local/AFP (joshua.melvin@thelocal.com)

Your comments about this article

Today's headlines
Did Paris pinch its 2024 Olympic Games logo?
The Paris Olympic logo, left, and 4 Global, right.

Did Paris pinch its 2024 Olympic Games logo?
35 minutes ago

The logo sure looks familiar...

Hollande brings former PM back in from the cold
Jean-Marc Ayrault. Photo: AFP

Hollande brings former PM back in from the cold
1 hour ago

Former prime minister Jean-Marc Ayrault has been named as France's new foreign minister.

Seven held in northern France for attacking migrants
Photo: AFP

Seven held in northern France for attacking migrants
2 hours ago

Seven men from northern France were held for attacking Iraqi-Kurds with iron bars who were trying to get onto UK-bound lorries.

Five ways France throws money down the drain
Photo: AFP

Five ways France throws money down the drain
4 hours ago

France needs to raise the cost of taking the Paris Metro, according to a report into how the country is wasting money.

French taxi wars
Uber bosses in court as French taxis demand €100m
Manager of Uber France Thibaud Simphal. Photo: AFP

Uber bosses in court as French taxis demand €100m
5 hours ago

The trial of two French executives from Uber was due to start in Paris on Thursday and it could be a costly one for both them and the company.

Opinion
What happened to liberté, égalité, fraternité in France?
Whatever happened to liberté, égalité and fraternité? Photo: AFP

What happened to liberté, égalité, fraternité in France?
6 hours ago

Some would say it was always an impossible motto to live up to, but since the terror attacks of last year France seems to have abandoned its founding principles altogether.

Six pupils killed in second school bus crash in France
Photo: AFP

Six pupils killed in second school bus crash in France
6 hours ago

Six pupils were killed in the second fatal school bus crash in France in just two days, after a truck's side panel sliced through the side of the vehicle.

France's deadliest coach crashes since 1973
A crash in Beaune, in 1982, saw 53 dead (including 44 children). Photo: AFP

France's deadliest coach crashes since 1973
8 hours ago

France has seen two fatal school bus this week, with eight pupils in total losing their lives. These accidents mark the latest in a long line of fatal crashes in recent years.

'France just isn't what it was,' says Donald Trump
Photo: AFP

'France just isn't what it was,' says Donald Trump
10 hours ago

US presidential candidate Donald Trump reckons France has changed for the worse and that he would have saved the day if he'd been at the Bataclan the night it was attacked by kalashnikov-wielding suicide bombers.

Stripping French citizenship: What all the fuss is about
Photo: AFP

Stripping French citizenship: What all the fuss is about
11 hours ago

It's provoked an almighty storm in France but what's all the fuss about?

Sponsored Article
US taxes and FATCA: 'The time for hiding is over'
National
France's deadliest coach crashes since 1973
Sponsored Article
Back to Boho chic: Win your new season wardrobe
Business & Money
Champagne and cognac lead record French alcohol exports
Politics
Scandals and deals: Fabius bows out (but he won't be short of cash)
Society
The English called 'barbarians' after this 'massacre' of French crepes
National
This terrifying video shows why you should avoid the sea during a storm
Lifestyle
A closer look at the 11 different American expats you'll meet in France
Gallery
Ten reasons why France is a great place to work
Politics
Why France is unlikely to force UK to move border back home
Society
The French foods you need to eat (in moderation) to stay healthy
Lifestyle
So where do all the Americans live in France and where do they avoid?
Public warned as gale force winds and giant waves lash the French coastline
Lifestyle
How Paris plans to become a 'model' of cleanliness - that's not a joke
Only in France - Pig's entrails, cheese and steak sold in vending machines
Travel
Wait... that's not snow! Check out France's most unique ski slope
Culture
Don't panic, France isn't bidding a final adieu to the circumflex
Culture
VIDEO: UK group performs Shakespeare for Calais refugees
National
France cuts more red tape: E.G. No license needed to collect horse's sperm
Gallery
How France could really simplify the French language (for us learners)
Culture
Say good bye to 'oignon': How 2,400 French words will get new spellings
Sport
US calls on French help to prevent 'Paris-style' attack at Super Bowl
Culture
Betty Blue star Béatrice Dalle says she ate a dead man's ear (while on acid)
Analysis & Opinion
It's no surprise the French are losing faith in Hollande's war on terror
Culture
What's on: Here are 10 great things to do in France in February
3,444
jobs available