• France's news in English

Euthanasia should be permitted: ethics council

AFP/The Local · 14 Feb 2013, 10:29

Published: 14 Feb 2013 10:29 GMT+01:00

France's medical ethics council said Thursday that assisted suicide should be allowed in exceptional cases when suffering patients make "persistent and lucid requests" in a step forward to legalising euthanasia.

Invoking a "duty to humanity," the body said that this should be permitted upon the "persistent, lucid and repeated requests from someone suffering from an ailment for which the treatment has become ineffective".

But it said the condition should be verified "not by a sole doctor but a medical team".

The council did not use the term euthanasia but spoke of "assisted death".

President Francois Hollande had referred a report on allowing assisted suicide to the council to examine the precise circumstances under which such steps could be authorised, with a view to producing draft legislation by June.

"The existing legislation does not meet the legitimate concerns expressed by people who are gravely and incurably ill," Hollande had said.

The report submitted to the council said physicians should be allowed to authorise interventions that ensure quicker deaths for terminal patients in three specific sets of circumstances.

In the first case, the patient involved would be capable of making an explicit request to that effect or have issued advance instructions in the event of him or her becoming incapable of expressing an opinion.

The second scenario envisages medical teams withdrawing treatment and/or nourishment on the basis of a request by the family of a dying patient who is no longer conscious and has not made any instructions.

The third would apply to cases where treatment is serving only to sustain life artificially.

France not about to have Swiss style clinics

The author of the report, Professor Didier Sicard, stressed that he did not support any measures which "suddenly and prematurely end life".

"We are radically opposed to inscribing euthanasia in law," Sicard told a press conference.

He also stressed that he was not advocating Swiss-style clinics where people are provided with lethal medication to enable them to end their own lives.

Instead, Sicard said he favoured amendments to a 2005 law which already authorises doctors to administer painkilling drugs at levels they know will, as a secondary effect, shorten a patient's life.

But France's Association for the Right to Die with Dignity (ADMD) says the report does not go far enough and its recommendations already exist in a previous 2005 law.

"The association, its 50 000 members, and the 94 percent of French people who support the legalization of euthanasia, demand a humane law that allows help to be given to someone at the end of their life, not after several weeks of starvation, but at the moment chosen by the patient themselves," ADMD  said in a statement.

"A gesture of humanity, perfectly regulated, and in full agreement with the patient whose wishes must be observed when they were expressed," the statement added.

The association wants France to introduce a law along the lines of those already in place in the Netherlands, Belgium and Luxembourg.

Sicard's report was drawn up after extensive consultation with the terminally ill and their families which revealed widespread dissatisfaction with a "cure at all costs" culture in the medical establishment.

According to France's national demographics council, there were about 3,000 euthanasia cases in the country annually on average, all of them illegal.

Related articles

AFP/The Local (ben.mcpartland@thelocal.com)

Your comments about this article

Today's headlines
Hero of French train attack stabbed in US
US Secretary of Defense Ashton Carter presents the Airman's Medal to Spencer Stone. Photo: AFP

Hero of French train attack stabbed in US

2 hours ago

Spencer Stone, one of the three Americans who helped foil a terror attack on a French train, is in hospital in California after being “repeatedly stabbed”, according to reports in the US.

Strike sees rubbish pile up on Paris streets
Rubbish piles up in front of a Parisian doorway. Photo: Patrick Auzou/Twitter

Strike sees rubbish pile up on Paris streets

3 hours ago

Around 3,000 tonnes of (extra) rubbish have accumulated on the streets of Paris as a strike by the city's rubbish collectors enters its fourth day.

France set to slaughter Alps mountain goats
Hundreds of Ibex or Bouquetin are set to be slaughtered in the Alps; Photo: AFP

France set to slaughter Alps mountain goats

3 hours ago

Wildlife groups have been angered by plans to cull hundreds of wild mountain goats in the Haut-Savoie region of the French Alps. But authorities insist they have the action is justified.

France is the future, says boss of US tech giant
France's Economy Minister Emmanuel Macron with Cisco chief John Chambers. Photo: AFP

France is the future, says boss of US tech giant

4 hours ago

France and its Socialist government have been given a ringing endorsement from the boss of an American multinational, who believes the country is about to profoundly change. Air France executives might not agree, however.

Refugee crisis
France wants creation of EU border guard corps
France wants an EU border corps to protect bloc's borders. Photo: AFP

France wants creation of EU border guard corps

6 hours ago

France has made a move to secure Europe's borders by proposing to other member states that an EU border guard corps could be set up to help deal with the tide of migrants and refugees heading into the EU.

Frenchman Platini hit with suspension by Fifa
Sepp Blatter and Michel Platini have both been suspended from Fifa. Photo: AFP

Frenchman Platini hit with suspension by Fifa

7 hours ago

Uefa president Michel Platini has been hit with a suspension by world football governing body Fifa along with the organisation's president Sepp Blatter.

Uber announces 20 percent fare cuts in Paris
Uber is facing stiff competition in Paris. Photo: AFP

Uber announces 20 percent fare cuts in Paris

8 hours ago

Ride-booking service Uber said on Thursday that it would reduce passenger prices in the French capital by 20 percent in a bid to keep up with competition.

JobTalk France - Graduate job hunting
Start with start-ups: Find a graduate job in France
Paris is home to plenty of job fairs, all worth checking out if you're a graduate. Photo: AFP

Start with start-ups: Find a graduate job in France

9 hours ago

Paris-based graduate and job hunter Ellie O'Driscoll offers some sound advice on how to land employment in France after finishing university. You can start with start-ups, she says.

Angry French rail users go on 'no-ticket' strike
A file image of rail users stranded in Gare de Lyon in Paris. Photo: AFP

Angry French rail users go on 'no-ticket' strike

9 hours ago

French rail passengers are going on strike on Thursday and Friday, by refusing to show valid tickets in a protest against a service that one train user group head described as something out of the "third world".

Race: Lines blur between French right and far-right
Nicolas Sarozy and Nadine Morano in happier times. Photo: AFP

Race: Lines blur between French right and far-right

11 hours ago

The row over a French MP's comments about France being "a country of white race" has highlighted the "tightrope" Nicolas Sarkozy's party is walking as it desperately tries to win votes from Marine Le Pen's far-right.

The pro-women French TV commercial that was axed because it was too sexist
The secret to more travel for less
French bakers in trouble with the law for... working too often
What's on in France: Ten great things to do in October
French car makes it from Paris to Bordeaux... without a driver
This pic was enough to see a French beauty queen stripped of her crown
Analysis & Opinion
Opinion: Tearing suits of Air France execs isn't great for France's image
Opinion: France should follow UK and teach drivers not punish them
Paris: See how rundown Gare du Nord became one big disco
When angry French workers target their bosses (and it pays off)
French Riviera floods: Marineland park left under sea of mud
IN PICTURES: French Riviera ravaged by 'apocalyptic' floods
Looters arrested after deadly floods strike southern France
Eight top vegetarian restaurants in France
Indecent exposure: French cops drop trousers at British war memorial
Please France can we just have one emergency phone number
French study: Passive smoking likely to cause kids behavioural problems
Here are 12 reasons why it's worth staying in France
Locals shocked as Nazi banner unfurled in Nice
Burger King to swallow up Quick in France then take on 'McDo'
OPINION: France's jobless benefit system shouldn't be derided
A Day Without Cars: The ten Paris streets you just have to walk down
Revealed: The 12 new zones for late-night and Sunday shopping in Paris
jobs available